Cancer treatment · BMC Med · 2026
Summary: no severe side effects from the treatment. The paper’s own results: two, one fatal.
Patients, of 87, with severe side effects rated as caused by the treatment
The paper says
A modified herpes virus, injected into tumors, had its first test in people with advanced cancer. For the 87 patients in the study’s main part, the paper’s opening summary reports no severe side effects from the treatment and calls its safety “favorable”.
Its own data show
The paper’s own table counts 2 of 87 patients with severe side effects it rates as caused by the treatment. Its results name them: a head and neck cancer patient who died after severe breathing difficulty, and a sarcoma patient with severe anemia (too few red blood cells).
A first test in people is mainly a test of safety. Later the paper contradicts itself, saying none of the 6 deaths it lists, one from breathing difficulty, was caused by the treatment. Either way, the anemia case alone makes the summary’s “none” wrong. The death was in head and neck cancer, where the paper says the treatment looked best.