Liver transplants · JAMA Netw Open · 2026
The summary: sicker patients were sent for transplant assessment less often. The paper’s numbers: more often.
Are sicker patients sent for transplant assessment more often, or less?
The paper says
The paper studied 325 patients with severe liver inflammation caused by alcohol. Its summary, the short overview at the top, says patients scoring higher on a 6-to-40 liver-sickness scale (higher means sicker) had “lower” odds of being sent for a transplant assessment.
Its own data show
Patients who were sent were sicker, averaging 32.3 points on the score against 27.4 for those not sent. In the very sentence that says “lower”, the summary itself prints 1.13; above 1 means more likely. The results section, later in the paper, repeats 1.13 and calls it “increased odds”. Only the word “lower” is wrong.
The 1.13 measures how the chances of being sent changed with each extra point of sickness: above 1 means more likely, below 1 less likely. Even the lowest value the paper thinks plausible, 1.07, is above 1. Someone reading only the summary would think the sickest patients are being passed over: the opposite of what happened.