Paperonium

← Back to the plain-language case

Abstract calls a MELD–referral odds ratio of 1.13 "lower referral odds"

JAMA Netw Open (2026) · doi:10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2026.2567 · PMC13003376

Summary

The study follows 325 patients hospitalized with severe alcohol-associated hepatitis at 5 US transplant centers and models referral for liver transplant evaluation. The abstract states that "higher MELD scores were associated with lower referral odds" and gives, in the same sentence, an odds ratio of 1.13 (95% CI 1.07–1.18; P < .001). An odds ratio above 1, with a confidence interval wholly above 1, means that higher MELD scores go with higher odds of referral. The Results text, Table 2, Table 1 (mean MELD 32.3 in referred vs 27.4 in non-referred patients) and Supplement 1 eTable 3 all show that direction. All the numbers agree with each other. The error is a single direction word in the abstract, which reverses the stated direction of the association for one of the study's primary outcomes.

What the paper reports

Abstract, Results:

In multivariable analysis, higher MELD scores were associated with lower referral odds (odds ratio, 1.13 [95% CI, 1.07-1.18]; P < .001).

Results, "Factors Associated With Referral for Transplant Evaluation", paragraph 1:

In multivariable logistic regression, adjusting for age, sex, race, ethnicity, educational level, insurance, marital status, living with children, MELD score, ADI, and site of care, a higher MELD score was associated with increased odds of referral (odds ratio [OR], 1.13 [95% CI, 1.07-1.18]; P < .001) (Table 2).

Table 2 (Multivariable Logistic Regression Analyses at Each Step in the Liver Transplant Cascade), referral column (n = 299):

MELD score (≤40)c | 1.13 (1.07-1.18) | <.001

Table 2, footnote c (the same definition appears in Table 1 and in the Methods):

Scores range from 6 to 40, with higher scores indicating severe liver disease.

Results, "Patient Characteristics", paragraph 3, and Table 1:

Compared with those who were not referred, patients who were referred for LT evaluation had significantly higher mean (SD) MELD scores (32.3 [7.7] vs 27.4 [6.9]; P < .001)

Discussion, paragraph 2:

As expected, the MELD score was associated with the transplant cascade.

Supplement 1, eTable 3 (referral model with an insurance-by-site interaction), row "Meld_cap": estimate 0.1432, standard error 0.0284, Wald χ² 25.4024, P < .0001.

All quotes from the article were checked verbatim against the PMC-archived text with src/show.py PMC13003376 --grep. The eTable 3 values were read from the supplement PDF.

What the paper's own numbers show

Method. In a logistic model, OR = exp(β). An OR above 1 means a positive coefficient: the odds of the outcome (here, referral) rise as the covariate rises. I converted the printed OR and CI bounds to the log scale and took the standard error from the CI width to get a z statistic. I compared the abstract's numbers with the Results text and Table 2. I computed the OR that a "lower odds" statement would need, which is the reciprocal OR per one-point lower MELD. I converted the eTable 3 coefficient to an OR with a Wald CI. As a descriptive check, I compared the Table 1 MELD means by referral status with a Welch t test, and approximated the crude logistic slope with the normal-discriminant formula (difference in means divided by pooled variance). That approximation is unadjusted and assumes normal MELD distributions with equal variances. It is used only to check the sign. All calculations are in recompute.py.txt.

Quantity Location Reported Recomputed
MELD → referral, adjusted OR Abstract, Results 1.13 (1.07–1.18), P < .001, described as "lower referral odds" ln OR = +0.122; ln CI bounds +0.068 and +0.166, both > 0; z = 4.90, p ≈ 1.0 × 10⁻⁶: higher odds
MELD → referral, adjusted OR Results, paragraph 1 1.13 (1.07–1.18), P < .001, "increased odds" Same numbers as the abstract; direction word consistent with them
MELD → referral, adjusted OR Table 2, referral column 1.13 (1.07–1.18), P < .001 Geometric CI midpoint 1.124, consistent with 1.13
Size of the effect derived — +13% odds per MELD point (CI +7% to +18%); 1.13¹⁰ = 3.39 (1.97–5.23) per 10 points
OR that "lower odds" would require derived not reported anywhere 1/1.13 = 0.885 (0.847–0.935), per 1-point lower MELD
Sensitivity referral model Supplement 1, eTable 3, Meld_cap β = 0.1432, SE 0.0284, χ² 25.40, P < .0001 (β/SE)² = 25.42; OR = 1.154 (1.091–1.220): higher odds
Mean MELD, referred vs not referred Table 1; Results, Patient Characteristics 32.3 (7.7) vs 27.4 (6.9), P < .001; SMD 0.68 Difference +4.9 points; Welch t = 5.75 (df 228), p = 2.9 × 10⁻⁸; SMD 0.67
Crude OR per MELD point (approximation) from Table 1 — Pooled SD 7.21; slope 0.0944; OR ≈ 1.099 (> 1)
Referral rate Abstract; Results 120 (36.9%) 120/325 = 36.9%

Every number in the abstract sentence matches the Results and Table 2. The adjusted estimates, the sensitivity model and the descriptive data all point the same way: patients with higher MELD scores were more likely to be referred. Only the word "lower" in the abstract disagrees.

Figure

The abstract and the Results give the same odds ratio with opposite direction words

Figure 1. On the left is the abstract's sentence and on the right the Results text and Table 2 row. Both are short excerpts, and both printed estimates are shown in orange: OR 1.13 (95% CI 1.07–1.18), P < .001. The double arrow marks the conflict: the numbers are identical, but the abstract says "lower" and the Results say "increased". The blue box gives values recomputed from the printed numbers. The log OR and both log CI bounds are positive (z = 4.9), which contradicts "lower" and supports "increased". The Table 1 means (32.3 in referred vs 27.4 in non-referred patients) point the same way.

Odds ratio for referral per MELD point: printed values, recomputed values and the reciprocal that "lower" would require

Figure 2. Odds ratios for referral per 1-point higher MELD score, on a log axis with a thin reference line at OR = 1. Orange: the estimate as printed in the abstract and in the Results and Table 2. It is identical in both places and lies entirely to the right of 1. Blue: values recomputed from the paper's own numbers. These are the eTable 3 sensitivity model, exp(0.1432 ± 1.96 × 0.0284) = 1.154 (1.091–1.220), and the crude normal-discriminant approximation from the Table 1 means (1.099, point estimate only), both above 1. The hollow blue marker is the reciprocal, 1/1.13 = 0.885 (0.847–0.935). This is the estimate a "lower referral odds" statement would require. The paper does not report it.

Why it matters

The abstract is the part of a paper that most readers see, and the part that indexing services, evidence summaries and citing articles most often take statements from. Referral is one of the study's primary outcomes, and MELD is one of its two named exposures. As printed, the abstract sentence tells a reader that sicker patients were less likely to be referred for transplant evaluation. That would be a clinically surprising result, and it is the opposite of what the paper's analysis shows. A reader who knows how to read an odds ratio can see that the sentence contradicts itself. A reader who takes in only the words, or a tool that extracts the claim from the text, would record the reversed direction.

The consequences are limited. No number is wrong, and the significance and size of the estimate are as printed: each additional MELD point goes with about 13% higher adjusted odds of referral. The title, Key Points and abstract Conclusions do not mention the MELD main effect. The Results, Table 2, Table 1, the Discussion and the supplement are all consistent with each other. The paper's headline finding is unaffected. That finding is the MELD × ADI interaction at intermediate MELD scores (P for interaction = .01) and the referral probabilities by ADI band, and neither depends on this sentence. The ADI, wait-listing, transplant and mortality results are also unaffected.

Explanations considered

The evidence fits a single wrong direction word in the abstract's Results paragraph. Nothing in the paper shows how it arose.

Status

As of 2026-10-23:

Sources: publisher full text; PMC13003376; Europe PMC REST full-text XML and supplementary files for PMC13003376; Crossref REST API for doi:10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2026.2567.

Suggested correction

Abstract, Results. Replace "In multivariable analysis, higher MELD scores were associated with lower referral odds (odds ratio, 1.13 [95% CI, 1.07-1.18]; P < .001)." with:

In multivariable analysis, higher MELD scores were associated with higher referral odds (odds ratio, 1.13 [95% CI, 1.07-1.18]; P < .001).

The numbers stay as printed, and they match the Results text, Table 2 and Supplement 1. No other part of the paper needs to change.