Artificial arteries · Nat Commun · 2025
Paper: luck produces its arteries’ advantage under 1 in 100 times. Its counts: 1 in 16.
How often luck alone would produce this advantage if both kinds work equally well
The paper says
In rabbits, after 2 weeks, 18 of 20 new artificial arteries (90%) were still open to blood flow, against 3 of 6 standard ones (50%). The paper says luck alone would produce an advantage this big under 1 time in 100.
Its own data show
The calculation the paper names gives about 1 in 16 on those counts, missing even the paper’s own bar for “significant”: 1 in 20. With 3 of 6 standard ones open, that calculation needs a perfect 20 of 20 to get under 1 in 100. Other standard calculations reach about 1 in 70 at best.
The odds answer one question: if both kinds of artery worked equally well, how often would luck alone produce an advantage this big? Under 1 in 20 earns the label “significant”. With only 6 standard arteries, 90% versus 50% is a promising hint, not proof, that the new design is better. The paper’s “significantly outperformed” overstates it.