Paperonium

Protein structure · Commun Biol · 2025

This protein shape’s quality table describes another crystal, making the shape look better than it is

A full boxThe table’s box, 1 copy55% fullSame box, text’s 4 copies220%impossibleIts database, 4 copies46% full0%50%100%150%200%250%
A full boxThe table’sbox, 1 copy55% fullSame box, text’s 4 copies220%impossibleIts database,4 copies46% full0%50%100%150%200%250%

The paper’s quality table versus its own text, figures and database entry

The paper says

The paper maps a protein’s 3D shape by X-raying its crystal, which is one tiny box of protein and water copied over and over. Its quality table lists one copy per box, sharpness 1.45 Å (smaller is sharper) and error score 21.9% (lower is better).

Its own data show

Its text and figures show four copies per box; the text gives a blurrier 1.98 Å. Its public Protein Data Bank entry agrees, with error score 27.5%. In the table’s crystal, one copy fills 55% of a box, so four would need 4 × 55% = 220%. The entry’s crystal fits four (46% full).

A quality table says how far to trust a protein shape: its sharpness, and its error score, the gap between X-ray measurements and the shape’s predictions. This table fits a different crystal; the paper never says which. The real shape’s quality table is not in the paper; the database’s numbers are noticeably worse. The paper’s main findings are not contradicted.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

AcrIIA19 binds to the WED domain and inhibits various Cas9 orthologs at multiple stages · Commun Biol (2025) · doi:10.1038/s42003-025-09417-6