Protein structure · Commun Biol · 2025
This protein shape’s quality table describes another crystal, making the shape look better than it is
The paper’s quality table versus its own text, figures and database entry
The paper says
The paper maps a protein’s 3D shape by X-raying its crystal, which is one tiny box of protein and water copied over and over. Its quality table lists one copy per box, sharpness 1.45 Å (smaller is sharper) and error score 21.9% (lower is better).
Its own data show
Its text and figures show four copies per box; the text gives a blurrier 1.98 Å. Its public Protein Data Bank entry agrees, with error score 27.5%. In the table’s crystal, one copy fills 55% of a box, so four would need 4 × 55% = 220%. The entry’s crystal fits four (46% full).
A quality table says how far to trust a protein shape: its sharpness, and its error score, the gap between X-ray measurements and the shape’s predictions. This table fits a different crystal; the paper never says which. The real shape’s quality table is not in the paper; the database’s numbers are noticeably worse. The paper’s main findings are not contradicted.