Paperonium

← Back to the plain-language case

Table 1 crystallographic statistics do not match the AcrIIA19 structure described in the text and deposited

Commun Biol (2025) Β· doi:10.1038/s42003-025-09417-6 Β· PMC12855784

Summary

The paper's central result is a crystal structure of the anti-CRISPR protein AcrIIA19. The Results text describes it as a C222₁ crystal with four molecules in the asymmetric unit (ASU), solved at 1.98 Γ…, and refers the reader to Table 1 for the crystallographic statistics. Table 1 instead reports a tetragonal P4₁2₁2 cell (a = b = 64.43, c = 62.82 Γ…), data to 1.45 Γ… and one molecule in the ASU. These cannot describe the same crystal: four molecules per ASU in Table 1's cell would give a Matthews coefficient of 0.56 Γ…Β³/Da, far below the physical minimum. The deposited entry the paper cites (PDB 9WA8) agrees with the text, not with Table 1, so the published data-collection and refinement statistics (resolution, R factors, completeness, B factors, atom counts, geometry) do not appear to belong to the structure the paper analyses.

What the paper reports

Results, "High-resolution structural analysis of AcrIIA19 reveals a previously uncharacterized structural fold", paragraph 1:

Following successful crystallization, the structure of AcrIIA19 was solved at a 1.98 Γ… resolution using MR, with the AlphaFold2 model used as a search template. Details on crystallographic and refinement statistics are listed in Table 1.

Same section, paragraph 2:

The crystal belonged to space group C2221 and contained four molecules (MolA to MolD) in the asymmetric unit (ASU; Fig. 1 C). The final structural model covered the complete AcrIIA19 (residues M1 to G115).

B-factor analysis showed relatively higher values at the N-terminus; however, the overall B-factor was low (average 48.8 Γ…), indicating that the structure was highly rigid (Fig. 1G).

The observation that all four molecules in the same ASU exhibited nearly identical structures served as additional indirect evidence supporting the high structural stability of AcrIIA19 (Fig. 1H).

Table 1, "Data collection and refinement statistics" (selected rows, as archived):

Space group | P 41 21 2

a, b, c (Γ…) | a = 64.43, b = 64.43, c = 62.82

Resolution range (Γ…) | 28.81–1.45

Total reflections | 616,092

Unique reflections | 24,054

Wilson B-factor (Γ…2) | 20.90

Rwork (%)a | 20.91 (27.03)

Rfree (%)a | 21.89 (25.83)

No. of molecules in the asymmetric unit | 1

No. of non-hydrogen atoms | 821

Macromolecules | 733

Average B-factor values (Γ…b) | 23.55

(Both resolution-range rows, under "Data collection" and under "Refinement", read 28.81–1.45. On the publisher's page the space group is typeset P 4₁ 2₁ 2.)

Figure 1 legend, panels C and H:

C Four molecules of AcrIIA19 in the same crystallographic asymmetry unit (ASU).

H Four superimposed AcrIIA19 structures in ASU.

Results, "AcrIIA19 forms a stable dimer in solution", paragraph 2:

The PISA complex formation score, which ranges from 0 to 1 with higher values indicating greater biological relevance, was 1.0 for both the AB and CD dimers.

Since the AB dimer and CD dimer represent essentially the same dimeric form (Fig. 2C, D), we selected the AB dimer as a representative structure to analyze in detail.

Data availability (back matter):

The coordinate and structural factors have been deposited in the Research Collaboratory for Structural Bioinformatics (RCSB) Protein Data Bank (PDB) under the PDB code 9WA8.

What the paper's own numbers show

Method. I compared the three crystallographic descriptors the text gives (space group, resolution, ASU content) with Table 1. I then tested whether each description is physically self-consistent. For each cell I computed the volume, and from it the Matthews coefficient Vm = V / (n_sym Γ— n_mol Γ— M), with n_sym = 8 general positions (true of both P4₁2₁2 and C222₁) and M = 14,545 Da, the chain mass of the deposited construct (residues 1–115 plus the LEHHHHHH tag). I counted the non-hydrogen atoms of a complete residue 1–115 chain from its sequence, and I enumerated the symmetry-unique reflections that Table 1's cell, space group and resolution range allow. Finally I compared both descriptions with the deposited entry PDB 9WA8 (RCSB metadata, coordinates and wwPDB validation report). Every number below is printed by recompute.py.txt.

Quantity Location Reported Recomputed
Space group Results ΒΆ2 vs Table 1 C222₁ (text); P4₁2₁2 (Table 1) Orthorhombic vs tetragonal: different crystal systems, not alternative settings. PDB 9WA8: C 2 2 2₁
High-resolution limit Results ΒΆ1 vs Table 1 1.98 Γ… (text); 28.81–1.45 Γ… (Table 1, both rows) Differ by 0.53 Γ… (26.8% of 1.98). PDB 9WA8: 28.95–1.98 Γ…
Molecules in the ASU Results ΒΆ2, Fig. 1C/H vs Table 1 four (MolA to MolD); 1 PDB 9WA8: 4 chains (A–D)
Cell Table 1 a = b = 64.43, c = 62.82 Γ… Tetragonal metric (a = b), consistent with P4₁2₁2. V = 260,780 Γ…Β³. PDB 9WA8 cell 63.41 Γ— 98.98 Γ— 196.66 Γ…, V = 1,234,301 Γ…Β³ (4.73Γ— larger)
Matthews coefficient, Table 1 cell, 1 molecule per ASU derived from Table 1 β€” 2.24 Γ…Β³/Da (45% solvent): normal
Matthews coefficient, Table 1 cell, 4 molecules per ASU derived from Table 1 + text β€” 0.56 Γ…Β³/Da: impossible (protein crystals typically lie at about 1.7–3.5)
Matthews coefficient, deposited cell, 4 molecules per ASU PDB 9WA8 β€” 2.65 Γ…Β³/Da (54% solvent); the entry itself records 2.65 and 53.62%
Protein non-H atoms Table 1 vs sequence 733 One complete chain M1–G115 has 946 (deposited chains C and D: 945 each), so 733 is 0.77 of one complete chain; four chains need about 3784. PDB 9WA8: 3845
Unique reflections Table 1 24,054 at 99.98% complete Table 1's cell and space group allow 24,053 to 28.81–1.45 Γ…: consistent. The deposited cell would allow 109,549 over that range
Multiplicity Table 1 25.6 616,092 / 24,054 = 25.6: consistent. PDB 9WA8 redundancy 13.2
R-work / R-free Table 1 vs PDB 9WA8 20.91 / 21.89% PDB 9WA8: 23.88 / 27.5%; 42,609 reflections in refinement vs Table 1's 24,052
Average B-factor Results ΒΆ2 vs Table 1 48.8 (text); 23.55, Wilson 20.90 (Table 1) PDB 9WA8: mean atomic B 64.4, Wilson B 50.9 (validation report). The text's value is not reproduced by either source; it is far from Table 1's

Table 1 is internally consistent: its cell is tetragonal as its space group requires, the reflection count matches the cell and resolution almost exactly, the multiplicity matches its totals, and the atom count fits a single chain. It therefore reads as a complete statistics table for a single-chain, 1.45 Γ…, P4₁2₁2 crystal. The Results text, the Figure 1 and 2 legends, the dimer analysis and the deposited entry all describe a different crystal: C222₁, 1.98 Γ…, four chains. Table 1's model is also not a complete 1–115 chain, which the text says the final model is.

Figure

Results text and Table 1 give incompatible crystallographic descriptions; the deposited entry matches the text

Figure 1. The four descriptors on which the Results text and Table 1 disagree, as printed (orange). Each connector names the conflict. The blue lines are recomputed from Table 1's own cell: with the eight symmetry copies of P4₁2₁2 and a 14,545 Da chain, one molecule per ASU leaves a normal 2.24 Γ…Β³/Da, while the text's four molecules would leave 0.56 Γ…Β³/Da, which is impossible. The gray strip gives the deposited entry PDB 9WA8 that the paper's Data availability statement names; it matches the text on space group, resolution and ASU content.

Matthews coefficients implied by each description

Figure 2. Matthews coefficient (unit-cell volume per dalton of protein) for each combination of cell and ASU content, on a scale starting at zero. The shaded band is the typical range for protein crystals (about 1.7–3.5 Γ…Β³/Da). Table 1's cell is plausible only with the one molecule Table 1 lists. The four molecules described in the text and in Figure 1C/H fit only the deposited C222₁ cell (2.65 Γ…Β³/Da, the value recorded in the PDB entry).

Why it matters

The crystal structure is the paper's headline deliverable ("Here, we present the crystal structure of AcrIIA19" in the Abstract). Table 1 is where a reader, referee or re-user checks its quality: resolution, completeness, R-work/R-free, geometry, Ramachandran statistics and B factors. As published, those numbers appear to describe a different crystal. The quality indicators a reader would rely on for the 1.98 Γ…, four-chain structure are therefore not in the paper. Its deposited R-free (27.5%) is noticeably higher than Table 1's 21.89%, and the deposited 1.98 Γ… resolution is lower than Table 1's 1.45 Γ….

The four-molecule ASU is not incidental. The near-identity of the four copies is offered as evidence of rigidity (Fig. 1H), and the dimer analysis (PISA scores for the AB and CD dimers, the AB interface, Fig. 2B–H) depends on four chains in the ASU. Those analyses are consistent with the deposited entry, so they are not themselves refuted; what is missing is the correct statistical description of the data behind them.

The main biological conclusions (a new fold, a homodimer in solution by SEC-MALS, WED-domain binding and inhibition of several Cas9 orthologs) rest largely on the deposited structure and on independent biochemical data, and are not contradicted by this problem.

Two smaller inconsistencies sit in the same section and do not change any conclusion. The Figure 2C legend says "The model shows two dimers formed by MolA/MolD and MolC/MolD", which names MolD twice, while the text analyses AB and CD dimers. The B-factor is given in Γ… in the text and "Γ…b" in Table 1, where Γ…Β² is meant.

Explanations considered

The paper does not say what crystal Table 1 describes. The average B-factor in the text (48.8) matches neither Table 1 (23.55) nor the deposited coordinates (mean 64.4; Wilson estimate 50.9). That leaves its source unclear.

Status

Suggested correction

  1. Replace Table 1 with the data-collection and refinement statistics for the deposited 9WA8 dataset: space group C222₁, cell 63.41 Γ— 98.98 Γ— 196.66 Γ…, 28.95–1.98 Γ…, four molecules per ASU, and the matching reflection counts, completeness, multiplicity, I/Οƒ(I), R-merge, R-work/R-free, atom counts, B factors and geometry. The values should match those in the PDB entry and its validation report.
  2. If the present Table 1 describes another AcrIIA19 crystal (or another protein) from the same work, identify it, state its relation to the structure analysed, and deposit it, or remove it.
  3. Reconcile the "average 48.8" B-factor in the Results with the corrected table, and give its unit as Γ…Β².
  4. Minor: correct the Figure 2C legend ("MolA/MolD and MolC/MolD") to the AB and CD dimers analysed in the text.