Paperonium

Nutrition · Epidemiology · 2026

“Less meat means 2 in 100 fewer with heart disease.” Its own table shows no change.

Summary: heart disease,less meat2 fewer in 100Table: heart disease,less meatno changeTable: healthy, less meat2 more: summary’s 2, flippedSummary: heart disease,whole grain2 fewer in 100Table: heart disease,whole grainno changeTable: healthy, whole grain2 more: summary’s 2, flipped−2−4−1−11−3−11−4 per 100−2024same as today’s diets
Summary: heartdisease, less meat2 fewer in 100Table: heartdisease, less meatno changeTable: healthy,less meat2 more:summary’s 2, flippedSummary:heart disease,whole grain2 fewer in 100Table: heartdisease,whole grainno changeTable: healthy,whole grain2 more:summary’s 2, flipped−2−4−1−11−3−11−4−2024same as today’s dietsper 100

Change per 100 people in 2050, new diets compared with today’s

The paper says

A computer simulation of health to 2050. The summary: two-thirds less red and processed meat means 2 in 100 fewer living with heart disease (likely range 1 to 4 fewer) and 2 fewer deaths. Doubling whole grain: the same (likely range 0 to 3 fewer).

Its own data show

The paper’s own table: 4 in 100 live with heart disease under today’s diets and both new ones: no change (likely range 1 fewer to 1 more). The summary’s figures are the table’s figures for people who stay healthy, 2 more (1 to 4; whole grain 0 to 3), with “more” turned into “fewer”.

The simulation puts everyone in 2050 into one of four groups: healthy, living with heart disease, dead after having it, dead without it. With less meat, out of 100 people, 2 more stay healthy, so 2 fewer die of any cause, while the 4 living with heart disease stay 4. The fewer-deaths claim holds; the less-heart-disease claim does not.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

Novel Pooling Method for Nonlinear Cohort Analysis and Meta-analysis Estimates: Predicting Health Outcomes from Dietary Changes · Epidemiology (2026) · doi:10.1097/EDE.0000000000001932