Paperonium

← Back to the plain-language case

Abstract reports a 2-point fall in IHD prevalence; the paper's Table 2 shows no change

Epidemiology (2026) Β· doi:10.1097/EDE.0000000000001932 Β· PMC12851546

Summary

The abstract and the Results say that a two-thirds cut in red and processed meat would lower the prevalence of ischemic heart disease (IHD) in 2050 by 2 percentage points (%pt), 95% prediction interval (PI) 1 to 4. They say a 100% increase in whole grain would lower it by 2%pt (PI 0 to 3). The paper's Table 2 gives an IHD difference of 0 (βˆ’1 to 1) for both scenarios, and its scenario and current-diet IHD levels are both 4%. The two figures in the text are exactly the Table 2 differences for the Healthy state (+2, 1 to 4 for meat; +2, 0 to 3 for whole grain), and the paper's own Discussion says these diets keep IHD prevalence constant. As a result, the abstract's IHD estimates, the meat estimate's PI that excludes zero, and the abstract conclusion that more plant-based diets reduce IHD prevalence are not supported by the paper's own projections. The mortality findings and the pooling method are not affected.

What the paper reports

Abstract, Results:

We estimated that a two-thirds reduction in red and processed meat consumption would decrease the prevalence of IHD by 2 (95% prediction intervals [PI] 1, 4) percentage points (%pt) in the 2017 cohort and deaths by 2%pt (95% PI 1, 4) by 2050. We estimated that a 100% increase in whole grain consumption would reduce IHD by 2%pt (95% PI 0, 3) and deaths by 2%pt (95% PI 0, 3).

Abstract, Conclusions:

Our estimates support the hypothesis that more plant-based diets reduce mortality and IHD prevalence.

Results, "Projections":

The large total scenario was associated with nearly 3 percentage points (%pt) increased prevalence of healthy individuals and over 4%pt lower deaths, but also increased the prevalence of IHD by 1 %pt. We estimate that a large reduction in meat consumption could decrease the prevalence of individuals with IHD by 2%pt (95% PI 1, 4) and reduce deaths by 2%pt (95% PI 1, 4) by 2050. For a large increase in whole grain consumption, the estimated decrease in prevalence of individuals with IHD was as high as 2%pt (95% PI 0, 3) and in deaths 2%pt (95% PI 0, 3).

Methods, "Projections" (how the IHD state and the differences are defined):

...and for IHD morbidity, those whose simulated time of IHD occurred before and death after the time point...

We compared the scenarios with the current diet scenario by calculating the differences in the state probabilities along their 95% PI.

Table 2, 2050 rows (state probability, %, with 95% PI; difference from current diets, %pt, with 95% PI):

Current diets | 2050 | Healthy 33 (32–34) | IHD 4 (3–5) | Dead w/o IHD 46 (45–47) | Dead w IHD 18 (17–19)
Large; Meat | 2050 | Healthy 35 (34–36), difference 2 (1–4) | IHD 4 (4 – 5), difference 0 (-1 to 1) | Dead w/o IHD 44 (43–45), difference -2 (-4 to 0) | Dead w IHD 17 (16–18), difference -1 (-2 to 1)
Large; Whole grain | 2050 | Healthy 34 (33–35), difference 2 (0–3) | IHD 4 (4 – 5), difference 0 (-1 to 1) | Dead w/o IHD 44 (43–46), difference -2 (-3 to 0) | Dead w IHD 17 (17–18), difference 0 (-1 to 1)

(Rows are shown here as one line per scenario; the cell values are as printed.)

Table 2 footer:

The differences of the large dietary change scenarios were calculated with respect to the current diets scenario in 2050.

Discussion, fifth paragraph:

Both reductions in red and processed meat, and increases in whole grain consumption would raise the prevalence of healthy individuals and reduce deaths by 2050, while maintaining the prevalence of IHD constant.

Conclusion:

We estimate that dietary changes, such as reducing red and processed meat consumption, and increasing whole grain intake, can improve cardiovascular health and reduce mortality. These findings align well with previous research and may have implications for policy actions.

What the paper's own numbers show

Method. I took the 2050 rows of Table 2 for current diets and for the large meat, whole grain and total scenarios. For each state I recomputed the difference from the printed levels (scenario minus current) and compared it with the printed difference. I then compared both with the figures in the text. A stated "decrease of 2 (PI 1, 4)" corresponds to a difference of βˆ’2 with PI βˆ’4 to βˆ’1 in the table's sign convention. Because the table rounds to whole percentage points, I also checked whether any unrounded values could make the text and table figures agree. I checked two other IHD definitions, the total-death figures, and the age and sex subgroups in Table 3. Every number below is printed by recompute.py.txt.

Quantity Location Reported Recomputed from the paper's own numbers
Meat: change in IHD prevalence, 2050 Abstract; Results decrease of 2 (95% PI 1, 4), i.e. βˆ’2 (βˆ’4 to βˆ’1) Table 2 IHD difference 0 (βˆ’1 to 1); levels 4 βˆ’ 4 = 0
Meat: could rounding reconcile them? Abstract vs Table 2 βˆ’2 vs 0 unrounded values that print as βˆ’2 lie in [βˆ’2.5, βˆ’1.5) and those that print as 0 lie in [βˆ’0.5, 0.5); the ranges do not overlap. The text's point estimate βˆ’2 is outside the table's PI (βˆ’1 to 1)
Meat: does the PI exclude zero? Abstract; Results vs Table 2 yes (1 to 4) no: Table 2 IHD PI is βˆ’1 to 1
Meat: change in Healthy prevalence Table 2 +2 (1–4) levels 35 βˆ’ 33 = +2. Same magnitude and PI as the text's IHD figure; it is the only Table 2 row that matches
Whole grain: change in IHD prevalence Abstract; Results decrease of 2 (95% PI 0, 3), i.e. βˆ’2 (βˆ’3 to 0) Table 2 IHD difference 0 (βˆ’1 to 1); levels 4 βˆ’ 4 = 0; no rounding overlap
Whole grain: change in Healthy prevalence Table 2 +2 (0–3) same magnitude and PI as the text's IHD figure (levels 34 βˆ’ 33 = +1, within rounding of +2). The Dead w/o IHD row, βˆ’2 (βˆ’3 to 0), also matches when read as a reduction
"Ever IHD" (IHD + dead with IHD), meat Table 2, derived β€” 22 β†’ 21, change βˆ’1 (summed differences 0 + (βˆ’1) = βˆ’1), not βˆ’2
"Ever IHD", whole grain Table 2, derived β€” levels 22 β†’ 21 (βˆ’1); summed differences 0 + 0 = 0
Meat: change in total deaths Abstract; Results decrease of 2 (95% PI 1, 4) levels (44 + 17) βˆ’ (46 + 18) = βˆ’3; summed death differences βˆ’2 + (βˆ’1) = βˆ’3; minus the change in the alive states βˆ’(2 + 0) = βˆ’2. The unrounded total lies between βˆ’3 and βˆ’2, so βˆ’2 is consistent. A PI for total deaths is not reported and cannot be derived from the two per-state PIs
Whole grain: change in total deaths Abstract; Results decrease of 2 (95% PI 0, 3) summed death differences βˆ’2 + 0 = βˆ’2; minus alive change βˆ’(2 + 0) = βˆ’2; consistent
Total scenario: Healthy, IHD, deaths Results, "Projections" "nearly 3", IHD "by 1", deaths "over 4" Table 2: +3 (2–4), +1 (0–2), and βˆ’6 + 2 = βˆ’4. The text matches the table here
Meat, IHD difference in age/sex subgroups Table 3 β€” 0, +1, 0, +1, +1, +1; none is βˆ’2
Sum of the four rounded state probabilities Table 2, 2050 β€” 101 (current), 100 (meat), 99 (whole grain), 100 (total): the cells are rounded independently

In both scenarios the IHD figure given in the text equals the Healthy-state difference in Table 2, in point estimate and in both PI limits. The IHD row of the same table shows no change, and so do the printed IHD levels (4% under every diet). The Discussion's statement that IHD prevalence stays constant agrees with the table. The same Results paragraph reads the total scenario's IHD row correctly (+1%pt), so the paragraph is not using a different IHD definition throughout.

Figure

The IHD reductions stated in the text match the Healthy row of Table 2, while the IHD row shows no change

Figure 1. Left: verbatim excerpts of the IHD figures in the abstract (the Results repeat them), with the stated values in orange. Right: the 2050 rows of Table 2 for the large meat and whole grain scenarios, giving the printed difference from current diets with its 95% PI. Beside it, in blue, is the same difference recomputed from the printed state levels. The solid arrow joins each text figure to the IHD row it describes, which shows 0 (βˆ’1 to 1). The dashed arrow joins it to the Healthy row, whose difference is identical to the text figure: +2 (1 to 4) for meat and +2 (0 to 3) for whole grain. The whole-grain Healthy levels give 34 βˆ’ 33 = +1, which is within rounding of the printed +2.

On one axis, the stated IHD changes lie away from the Table 2 IHD differences and mirror the Healthy differences

Figure 2. The differences from current diets in 2050, in percentage points (scenario βˆ’ current), on one axis, with the null value 0 as a thin vertical line. Orange: the IHD change stated in the abstract and Results, converted to the table's sign convention (βˆ’2, βˆ’4 to βˆ’1 for meat; βˆ’2, βˆ’3 to 0 for whole grain). Black open circles: the IHD difference printed in Table 2, 0 (βˆ’1 to 1), with the difference recomputed from the printed levels (4 βˆ’ 4 = 0) as a blue cross. Gray diamonds: the Healthy difference printed in Table 2, the mirror image of the stated IHD change. For meat, the stated interval excludes zero but the table's IHD interval does not. The stated point estimate lies outside the table's IHD interval in both scenarios.

Why it matters

Explanations considered

Status

Suggested correction

In the abstract, Results, replace

would decrease the prevalence of IHD by 2 (95% prediction intervals [PI] 1, 4) percentage points (%pt) in the 2017 cohort and deaths by 2%pt (95% PI 1, 4) by 2050. We estimated that a 100% increase in whole grain consumption would reduce IHD by 2%pt (95% PI 0, 3) and deaths by 2%pt (95% PI 0, 3).

with wording that follows Table 2, for example:

would increase the prevalence of healthy individuals by 2 (95% prediction intervals [PI] 1, 4) percentage points (%pt) in the 2017 cohort and reduce deaths by 2%pt by 2050, with no change in the prevalence of IHD (0%pt, 95% PI βˆ’1, 1). We estimated that a 100% increase in whole grain consumption would increase the prevalence of healthy individuals by 2%pt (95% PI 0, 3) and reduce deaths by 2%pt, with no change in IHD prevalence (0%pt, 95% PI βˆ’1, 1).

The authors would need to give the total-death PIs from their bootstrap draws. The same changes apply to the two sentences in the Results "Projections" paragraph. The abstract conclusion could read "Our estimates support the hypothesis that more plant-based diets reduce mortality", consistent with the Discussion's statement that IHD prevalence stays constant. If the authors intended a different IHD quantity for these two scenarios, the correction should define it and report its values, since none of the paper's tables contains a βˆ’2%pt IHD change.