Violence and injury · Lancet Reg Health Am · 2026
Shot women 379 times likelier to die in the ER, the paper says. Its table: 84.
Times as likely to die in the ER: each figure and its range
The paper says
The paper compares women treated in an emergency room (ER) after an assault: those who had been shot and those hurt some other way. Its discussion says the shot women were 379 times as likely to die in the ER (range 266 to 540).
Its own data show
Its own main table gives 83.82 times (range 72.38 to 97.06); 379 is 4.5 times that. The 379 and its range are the result of the first model the paper tried, printed in its supplement. The summary gives a third figure, 89 times, beside the main table’s range.
Figures like these come from a statistical model, a formula fitted to patient records. The paper says the first model it tried inflated its results because some groups had too few cases, so it switched to another. Its discussion quotes the dropped model’s figure as the risk, making the key finding 4.5 times too large.