Antibiotic resistance · PLoS Pathog · 2026
A paper’s summary says 84% of a superbug strain’s samples came from infections. Its count: 60%.
Share of this strain’s 164 samples that came from infections
The paper says
A Cape Town hospital kept samples of a superbug, a germ that survives the antibiotics doctors save for when others fail. One of its two most common strains (genetic families) turned up in 164 samples. The paper’s summary says 84% of those came from infections.
Its own data show
The paper’s results count 98 of the 164 (60%), and the spreadsheet of every sample published with it agrees. 84% isn’t even possible: the paper lists 186 infection samples in all, 51 of them (36 + 15) from two other strains, so this strain can have at most 135 (82%).
A person can carry this germ without being ill, so hospitals take two kinds of sample: from infections, and from checks for carriers. The paper suggests a strain found mostly in infections may cause more disease. At 60% that pattern survives (the other common strain: 22%), but the summary, the part most people read, makes the gap look far bigger.