Paperonium

Child nutrition · Lancet Reg Health Am · 2025

Eggs “did not benefit” babies’ development. The trial promised two tests beforehand; the paper reports one.

2020202120222023202420252026Trial runningMay 2021 to Aug 2023Mar 2026Registry after the paperstill 2 main testsDec 2025The paper1 main testno difference; its textnever names the other testMar 2020Public registration2 main testsfiled before any baby joinedJan 2024Data-analysis plandrops one of itstwo main tests withoutsaying so
Mar 2020Public registration2 main testsfiled before any baby joinedTrial runningMay 2021 to Aug 2023Jan 2024Data-analysis plandrops one of its two main testswithout saying soDec 2025The paper1 main testno difference; its textnever names the other testMar 2026Registry after the paperstill 2 main tests

Main tests of baby development: two registered before the trial, one in the paper

The paper says

Of 1,200 Maya babies in Guatemala, a randomly chosen group got an egg a day for six months; the rest did not. Afterwards, on a development questionnaire answered by caregivers, both groups scored about the same. The summary concludes eggs “did not benefit development”.

Its own data show

Before it started, the trial publicly registered two main tests: that questionnaire and a second test covering seven areas of development, such as language, movement and play. That list never changed. The paper’s text and tables never mention the second test or what became of it; nor does the data-analysis plan it cites.

Trials publicly list their main tests before starting, so they can’t later report only the flattering ones. Dropping one can be fine, but the reporting rules the paper says it follows require saying so and why. The paper itself warns caregivers’ answers may be skewed. Had the second test shown a benefit, the conclusion could be wrong; readers can’t check.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

Effect of eggs on Maya child development and growth: the Saqmolo’ Project randomized clinical trial · Lancet Reg Health Am (2025) · doi:10.1016/j.lana.2025.101339