Paperonium

Brain disease · Neurology · 2025

The summary makes the patients mostly men: 44% women. Its own table: 58% women.

44%The summary58%Its own table: 81 of 140too low0%255075100
44%The summary58%Its own table81 of 140too low0%255075100

Share of the same 140 patients who were women

The paper says

The paper studies 140 people with multiple system atrophy, a brain disease that affects movement, balance and automatic body functions. Its summary, the part most often read, says 44% were women, with symptoms starting at age 62.3 on average.

Its own data show

Its own table counts the same 140 patients as 59 men and 81 women: 58% women. It isn’t men and women swapped, either: men are 42%, not 44%. The same table puts the average age at first symptoms at 57.4 overall and 59.7 or younger in each of its 11 smaller groups of patients.

An average over several groups can’t be higher than the highest group’s average, so 62.3 can’t be right. Who was studied tells readers whom the findings apply to. Read alone, the summary makes a mostly female group look mostly male and 4.9 years older at first symptoms. The main results use neither wrong number.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

Multiple System Atrophy Without Dysautonomia · Neurology (2025) · doi:10.1212/WNL.0000000000214316