Air pollution · JAMA Network Open · 2025
Trimming pollution above the US limit clearly cuts strokes, the paper says. Its table can’t tell.
Change in stroke hospitalizations per 1,000 people over 5 years
The paper says
The summary: cutting fine-particle air pollution in the UK by 5% wherever it tops the US yearly limit would mean 2.26 fewer stroke hospitalizations per 1,000 people over 5 years (range: 8.97 to 20.64 fewer). Its key-points box says this would clearly reduce strokes.
Its own data show
The paper’s main results table, and an extra table published with it, give the same 2.26 fewer but a range of 8.97 fewer to 20.64 more. The table’s own risks agree: 12.32 in 1,000 without the cut, 3.37 to 32.97 with it; subtracting gives 8.95 fewer to 20.65 more.
A range is the span of results the data can’t rule out. It must contain the best guess, and a drop is clear only if the whole span is fewer strokes. The summary’s range misses 2.26; the table’s runs from fewer to more. The clear stroke cut claimed at the US limit, the threshold tied to current policy, is unsupported.