Paperonium

Medical research · BMC Med · 2025

The summary: 57.4% of trials’ data-sharing plans differ between registry and paper. Its own count: 42.6%.

Plans differ42.6%Its own count160 of 376The summary57.4%Plans matchthe summary used this row216 of 37640%45505560
Plans differ42.6%Its own count: 160 of 376The summary57.4%Plans matchthe summary used this row216 of 37640%45505560

Share of the 376 trials whose registry and paper plans differ or match

The paper says

This paper checked 376 medical trials. Each should state its plan for letting other researchers use its data in two places: a registry (a website listing trials and plans) and its published paper. The paper’s summary says over half, 216 (57.4%), have plans that differ.

Its own data show

This paper’s own detailed results and its main table of counts give those same 216 as the trials whose plans matched: 155 said yes to sharing in both places, 61 had no plan to share in either. The other 160 (42.6%) differ. Further on, the paper itself says “over 40%” differ.

Each trial’s two plans either match or differ, so the two shares must add up to 100%: 57.4% + 42.6%. The summary gave the matching share to the differing group, and the paper’s conclusions at the end repeat “more than half”. Those two parts are the most likely to be quoted; the paper’s own count says fewer than half differ.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

Practice of data sharing plans in clinical trial registrations and concordance between registered and published data sharing plans: a cross-sectional study · BMC Med (2025) · doi:10.1186/s12916-025-04328-z