Paperonium

Tuberculosis testing · BMJ Glob Health · 2025

Paper’s table: Xpert costs $14.59 per TB case, under TB-LAM’s $16.78. Fully priced, Xpert costs $21.80.

TB-LAM, priced in full: $16.78The paper’s table: Xpert$14.59, chemicals onlyXpert, priced in full$21.80 (discussion: $21.79)0510152025
TB-LAM, priced in full: $16.78The paper’stable: Xpert$14.59,chemicals onlyXpert,priced in full$21.80(discussion: $21.79)0510152025

Testing cost in US$ per TB case found, as the paper counts it

The paper says

The paper compares tuberculosis (TB) tests for people with HIV in Nigeria and picks one called TB-LAM. Its main results table puts the testing cost per TB case found at $16.78 for TB-LAM and $14.59 for a rival, Xpert. Its summary gives Xpert $20.

Its own data show

The $14.59 comes from a flowchart of who gets which test (Figure 1) that prices Xpert at $7.97 a test, its chemicals alone, without supplies, staff and equipment, but TB-LAM at its full $11.92. With the full Xpert price in its text, $21.01, it gives Xpert $21.80, the $21.79 its discussion reports.

Comparing prices is fair only if both count the same things. In the main table TB-LAM costs $2.19 more than Xpert, judged worth it; with Xpert at full price, TB-LAM costs $5.02 less. TB-LAM stays the paper’s pick either way, so this error does not change its advice, but no Xpert price in the paper gives the summary’s $20.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

Cost-effectiveness of different tuberculosis diagnostic approaches in Nigeria based on decision analytical modelling · BMJ Glob Health (2025) · doi:10.1136/bmjgh-2025-019270