Paperonium

Health costs · Lancet Global Health · 2025

Twice the odds of catastrophic health costs, give or take 0.1: too precise for 60⁠-⁠person groups

The summary2.0 give or take 0.1Narrowestrange 60 per group allowIts own appendix0.7 to 6.1: could be no difference1.9 to 2.1×1.13 to 3.53×0.5×1×2×5×10×no difference
The summary2.0 give or take 0.1Narrowestrange 60 pergroup allowIts own appendix0.7 to 6.1: could beno difference1.9×2.13.53×1.130.5×1×2×5×10×no difference

Times the odds, second-richest versus richest fifth, with the values not ruled out

The paper says

Of 296 people seeking care at five health centres and hospitals, 76 had what the paper calls catastrophic health costs. The summary says the second-richest fifth had 2.0 times the richest fifth’s odds of this, give or take 0.1 (1.9 to 2.1).

Its own data show

Its Table 1 has just 60 people in each group. With so few, the method the paper describes cannot give a range narrower than 1.13 to 3.53 (a span of 2.4, not 0.2). An alternative analysis in its own appendix gives 2.1, with a range of 0.7 to 6.1: that includes 1, no difference.

A range is the span of values the data can’t rule out; fewer people make it wider. Odds compare how many people hit such costs with how many didn’t. This is the summary’s only poverty result, and the paper’s claim that poverty drives these costs rests on it. With a range the data can support, it is borderline at best.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

Catastrophic health expenditure, social protection coverage, and financial coping strategies in adults with symptoms of chronic respiratory diseases in Kenya: a cross-sectional study · Lancet Global Health (2025) · doi:10.1016/S2214-109X(25)00061-0