Marine ecology · Proc Biol Sci · 2025
Paper: chance rarely makes one microbe disruption alter the other’s effect. Its numbers: 7 in 10.
How often chance alone makes one disruption seem to change the other’s effect
The paper says
Researchers disrupted microbes on parent seaweeds and on seabed-like tiles (some heat-sterilized), then counted their eggs attaching to the tiles. The summary concludes the two disruptions interact, each changing the other’s effect. The paper says chance alone would produce this under 1 time in 1,000.
Its own data show
The test boils the data down to one score: with no real interaction, about 1 is typical, and higher is harder for chance. The paper prints 0.771 (in its results and its appendix), lower than chance usually gives. Chance reaches 0.771 or more about 7 times in 10; under 1 in 1,000 needs over 3.16.
The score is worked out from the data; the odds are then looked up from the score, and 0.771 cannot give under 1 in 1,000. The score matches the appendix’s own figures, and fixing a slip there would lower it. So the printed numbers do not support the summary’s interaction claim. The parent-microbe result does match its own score.