Paperonium

Public health · Lancet Reg Health Am · 2025

Vaccines “prevented 144%” of intensive care admissions, which is impossible. The paper’s own counts give 59%.

Share prevented59%Its own counts12,997 of 22,017The summary and results144%impossibletoo high50%75100all 22,017 expected without vaccines
Share prevented59%Its own counts12,997 of 22,017The summary and results144%impossibletoo high50%75100all 22,017 expected without vaccines

Intensive care admissions vaccines prevented, as a share of the 22,017 expected without them

The paper says

The paper builds a points-based score to forecast how many Ontario COVID-19 patients will be in intensive care. Its opening summary and results section also say vaccines prevented 144% of intensive care admissions: 9,020 people were admitted, and its calculations expected 22,017 without vaccines.

Its own data show

Those two counts, printed beside the 144%, mean 22,017 − 9,020 = 12,997 admissions were avoided. The paper’s methods section calls its figure a “prevented fraction”: the share of expected admissions that were avoided. That is 12,997 ÷ 22,017 = 59%. The 144% is 12,997 ÷ 9,020, dividing by the admissions that did happen instead.

A share prevented asks: of the admissions there would have been without vaccines, what fraction never happened? It can’t pass 100%. The 144% answers another question: without vaccines, there would have been 144% more admissions than there were. A medical news report has already repeated it as a “144% reduction”. Corrected, vaccines still prevented about three in five expected admissions.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

Derivation and validation of a point-based forecasting tool for SARS-CoV-2 critical care occupancy: a population-based modeling study · Lancet Reg Health Am (2025) · doi:10.1016/j.lana.2025.101143