Paperonium

Genetics · PLoS Comput Biol · 2025

The summary says 49 of 48 DNA sites were fully read; the paper’s text supports 45.

45 of 48Its main textThe summary49 of 48impossible43 sites4445464748all the sites the study tracked
45 of 48Its main textThe summary49 of 48impossible43 sites45464748all the sites the study tracked

DNA sites fully read by the whole-DNA approach, out of the 48 tracked

The paper says

The study compares reading a person’s whole DNA with reading only stretches chosen in advance. It tracks 48 DNA sites linked to diseases or traits. Its summary says the whole-DNA approach fully read 49 of them (98%).

Its own data show

A count out of 48 can’t be 49, and 98% of 48 is about 47, so the summary contradicts itself. The results section names 3 sites not fully read, leaving 45 of 48 (94%), and the discussion section says 45. Both sections also state 92%, which would be about 44.

DNA-reading machines read DNA in short pieces. Here a site counts as fully read when at least 15 pieces each cover the whole site, end to end. The summary, which most readers see, gives 98% instead of about 94%. The main comparison holds: 44 or 45 is still far above the 4 of 48 the other method fully read.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

Analysis of targeted and whole genome sequencing of PacBio HiFi reads for a comprehensive genotyping of gene-proximal and phenotype-associated Variable Number Tandem Repeats · PLoS Comput Biol (2025) · doi:10.1371/journal.pcbi.1012885