Heart genetics · Circulation · 2024
“Heart-disorder patients have 45 times others’ odds of this DNA change.” Its own counts give 68.
Patients’ odds of carrying the change, as a multiple of the database’s odds
The paper says
Of 231 Thai patients with Brugada syndrome, a heart-rhythm disorder, 9 carried one particular rare DNA change; of 10,043 people in a Thai population gene database, 6 did. The paper and its summary put patients’ odds of carrying it at 45 times the database’s.
Its own data show
Odds here mean carriers per non-carrier. Patients: 9 carriers, 222 not, so 1 carrier for every 24.7 non-carriers. Database: 6 and 10,037, so 1 for every 1,673. Patients’ odds are 1,673 ÷ 24.7, about 68 times as high. No usual method gives 45; the printed 45.2 matches 6 patient carriers, not 9.
Comparing odds is division on printed counts: one right answer, no chance involved. The same division gives the paper’s other figure exactly: 20.2, from 1 carrier among 500 Thai comparison people (499 ÷ 24.7). The link holds, but the summary’s only number for its size is a third too low, and it is the number a reader would quote.