Psychiatry · Psychol Med · 2024
The summary’s numbers tie higher ADHD genetic scores to longer treatment; the results say the opposite.
Times the odds of persistent rather than brief treatment, as the genetic score rises
The paper says
A study of 10,577 people with early-onset depression relates genetic scores (DNA-based estimates of inherited tendency) to four treatment patterns. Its summary says higher ADHD scores meant lower odds of two longer patterns than of brief treatment, yet prints 1.06 and 1.12, which mean higher.
Its own data show
The results section and a supplement table give 0.91 (range 0.87 to 0.96) for prolonged initial treatment and 0.90 (range 0.83 to 0.97) for persistent treatment: 9% and 10% lower odds, as the summary’s words say. The summary’s 1.06 and 1.12, ranges included, match that table’s anorexia-score rows for the same two patterns.
Each figure is how many times the odds of a longer pattern, rather than brief treatment, are multiplied for each standard step up in the score: above 1 means higher odds, below 1 lower. The summary’s and the results’ ADHD ranges sit on opposite sides of 1. The summary’s numbers reverse what the paper calls its strongest result.