Health policy · Lancet Reg Health Eur · 2024
Summary: the biggest one-time gain, 19.67 points, came from feedback. Its table: from bonus pay.
Largest one-time gain on any care measure, in percentage points, by approach
The paper says
Catalonia’s clinics were scored on care measures, some carrying bonus pay, others only feedback (clinics saw their scores). The paper’s summary: feedback brought one-time jumps up to 19.67 points (bonus: 8.87); bonus pay made scores climb up to 6.66 points a year faster (feedback: 1.09).
Its own data show
The paper’s own table and results section give all four figures, and the smaller ones the summary lists beside them, to the other approach. The 19.67-point jump came on a bonus measure: the share of heavy drinkers who cut back. The 6.66 speed-up came on a feedback-only measure: correct diagnosis of heart and artery disease.
Scores were tracked before and after a measure got bonus pay or feedback, so a gain could be a one-time jump, a faster yearly climb, or both. The summary concludes feedback can match or beat bonuses. As printed, the jumps seem to support that; in fact they favor bonuses, 19.67 against 8.87. The climbs do support it, 6.66 against 1.09.