Heart valves · Eur Heart J · 2024
Women needing valve procedures got them less often than men. Summary: strong evidence. Its table: borderline.
How often chance alone gives the narrowed-valve gap if treatment were equal
The paper says
The summary, which most readers see first, says that with two diseases of one heart valve, women whom guidelines said needed a procedure had or were scheduled for one less often than men: gaps chance alone would produce under 1 time in 1,000.
Its own data show
Its results section and Table 3, for that same comparison, give about 1 in 20 (1 in 20.4) when the valve is narrowed, and about 1 in 29 when it leaks from a fault in the valve itself. No analysis in the paper gives under 1 in 1,000 for either.
“1 in 29” means: if women and men were treated alike, chance alone would produce a gap this big about 1 time in 29. The paper’s pass mark: less often than 1 time in 20. Both pass, the narrowed valve by a hair. The summary makes this borderline evidence look strong, and one of its three conclusions rests on it.