Cardiology · JAMA Netw Open · 2024
Heart trial’s original yardstick showed no clear win. The paper headlines one registered after the trial.
When the trial’s yardstick was registered and changed, and what the paper reports
The paper says
In a heart attack, doctors can open the blocked artery first, or X-ray all the heart’s arteries first for a full picture. The paper’s main result: opening first had the artery open within 10 minutes of the procedure starting for 51% of patients, versus 19%.
Its own data show
The trial first registered a different yardstick: the whole wait from hospital arrival to artery open. The paper reports it once, in its results: averaging 61.6 minutes opening first, 73 X-raying first. Pure chance would give a gap that big about 1 time in 8; scientists usually want 1 in 20 or rarer.
Trials publicly register their yardstick, the measure that decides success, so no one can pick the best-looking result after seeing the data. The paper itself never says its yardstick changed; only an extra file published alongside does. The decision to change it is undated: it may have come before the trial began or after results were seen.