Paperonium

Cardiology · JAMA Netw Open · 2024

Heart trial’s original yardstick showed no clear win. The paper headlines one registered after the trial.

202220232024Mar 2024The paperTop of the paper:new yardstick, 51%of patients opening first vs 19%X-raying firstIts results, once:original yardstick,average wait 61.6 minutes opening firstvs 73 X-raying first, could be chanceOctober 2023Registry editednew yardstick: artery open within10 minutes of the procedure startingApr 2022Public registryyardstick: whole wait fromhospital arrival to artery openApr 2023Trial ends
Apr 2022Public registryyardstick: whole wait fromhospital arrival to artery openApr 2023Trial endsOctober 2023Registry editednew yardstick: artery open within10 minutes of the procedure startingMar 2024The paperTop of the paper:new yardstick, 51% ofpatients opening first vs 19% X-raying firstIts results, once:original yardstick,average wait 61.6 minutes opening firstvs 73 X-raying first, could be chance

When the trial’s yardstick was registered and changed, and what the paper reports

The paper says

In a heart attack, doctors can open the blocked artery first, or X-ray all the heart’s arteries first for a full picture. The paper’s main result: opening first had the artery open within 10 minutes of the procedure starting for 51% of patients, versus 19%.

Its own data show

The trial first registered a different yardstick: the whole wait from hospital arrival to artery open. The paper reports it once, in its results: averaging 61.6 minutes opening first, 73 X-raying first. Pure chance would give a gap that big about 1 time in 8; scientists usually want 1 in 20 or rarer.

Trials publicly register their yardstick, the measure that decides success, so no one can pick the best-looking result after seeing the data. The paper itself never says its yardstick changed; only an extra file published alongside does. The decision to change it is undated: it may have come before the trial began or after results were seen.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

Culprit Lesion Coronary Intervention Before Complete Angiography in ST-Elevation Myocardial Infarction · JAMA Netw Open (2024) · doi:10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2024.3729