Paperonium

Family medicine · BMC Med · 2024

Summary: 4% more same-day emergency-room visits after stand-in doctors. The paper’s own table: no clear rise.

The summarya rise: whole range above 1×The paper’s own tablemaybe no rise: range includes 1×1.04×1.011.080.981.070.98×1×1.02×1.04×1.06×1.08×same chance as with a regular doctor
The summarya rise: whole rangeabove 1×The paper’sown tablemaybe no rise:range includes 1×1.04×1.011.080.981.070.95×1×1.05×1.1×same chance as with aregular doctor

How much likelier a same-day emergency visit is after a stand-in doctor

The paper says

The paper’s summary (the short paragraph at the top, often all people read) says patients were “4% more likely” to visit the emergency room that day after seeing a stand-in family doctor than a regular one: 1.04 times, range 1.01 to 1.08.

Its own data show

The paper’s main table, using the same patients and the same calculation, gives 1.02 times (2% more), with a range of 0.98 to 1.07. Its chart, its extra tables posted online with the paper, and its written results (“no difference”) all agree. Only the summary gives 1.04; nothing else in the paper supports it.

A range spans the values that fit the data. If it includes 1 (same chance), the data can’t tell a rise from no rise. So the question isn’t 4% or 2%, but whether there’s any rise. The summary tells readers stand-in doctors’ patients more often land in the emergency room that day; the paper’s own analysis doesn’t show that.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

Comparing the clinical practice and prescribing safety of locum and permanent doctors: observational study of primary care consultations in England · BMC Med (2024) · doi:10.1186/s12916-024-03332-z