Paperonium

Brain science · Sci Adv · 2022

Paper: light’s memory boost works through a brain signal. Its own range includes zero: maybe not.

Its results: “significant”needs a range all above 0Its results’ rangecrosses 0: maybe no part−0.107 to 0.706−0.200.20.40.60.8the signal plays no partagainst the gainadds to the gain
Its results:“significant”needs a range allabove 0Its results’ rangecrosses 0: maybeno part−0.107 to 0.706−0.400.40.8the signal plays no partagainst the gainadds to the gain

How much of the memory gain passes through the brain-wave signal

The paper says

Near-infrared light shone through the skull over the right forehead let people hold more items in mind. The paper’s summary, the part most people read, says the gain came through a brain-wave signal that grows with each item held. Its results call this “significant.”

Its own data show

The results label 0.300 the part of the memory gain that passes through the signal, with a range of −0.107 to 0.706. The paper’s methods count a result as significant (“no effect” ruled out) only if zero lies outside its range. Zero is inside, yet the sentence printing these numbers calls it “significant.”

A range spans every size the data can’t rule out; one that includes zero can’t rule out that the signal plays no part, which matters more here than the size. Yet the summary, a heading, a figure title and the discussion state this explanation as fact. The memory gain itself rests on separate tests and is untouched.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

Transcranial photobiomodulation enhances visual working memory capacity in humans · Sci Adv (2022) · doi:10.1126/sciadv.abq3211