Paperonium

Climate & refugees · Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A · 2023

The paper’s heavy-rain figures for 20 refugee settlements are an exact copy of its cold-spell figures.

The table’s cold-spell column1.29 daysThe table’s heavy-rain column1.29 days, the sameThe authors’ online chart1.96 heavy-rain days00.511.52
The table’s cold-spell column1.29 daysThe table’s heavy-rain column1.29 days, the sameThe authors’ online chart1.96 heavy-rain days00.511.52

Yearly heavy-rain and cold-spell days at Cox’s Bazar, one of the 20 settlements

The paper says

The paper compares weather at 20 refugee settlements with their countries’ averages. One table gives yearly heat-wave, cold-spell and heavy-rain days, averaged from 1981 to 2010 or 2018. Its summary says Cox’s Bazar, its one settlement in Bangladesh, gets more heavy rain than average.

Its own data show

For each settlement the table has three heavy-rain numbers: country average, settlement, difference. All 60 (20 × 3) equal the cold-spell numbers. Cox’s Bazar: 1.29 days to Bangladesh’s 1.62, below average. The authors’ charts, in files linked from the paper, give 1.96 heavy-rain days, above average, and 1.28 cold-spell days, close to the table’s 1.29.

Cold-spell days fall in runs of six or more unusually cold nights; heavy-rain days have over 20 mm of rain. Such different measures cannot agree to two decimals 60 times. So the paper prints no real heavy-rain counts for any settlement, and its table contradicts its summary’s one heavy-rain finding. Its main long-term temperature and rainfall findings use another table.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

Refugee settlements are highly exposed to extreme weather conditions · Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A (2023) · doi:10.1073/pnas.2206189120