Paperonium

Coastal science · Nat Commun · 2023

Summary: “the majority” of muddy coasts erode over a metre a year. Its own table: 30.5%.

Eroding30.5%Its own table“the majority”The summary: more than halfBarely moving40.3%Growing29.2%0%2040506080100
Eroding30.5%Its own table“the majority”The summary: more than halfBarely moving40.3%Growing29.2%0%20406080100

Share of all the world’s muddy coastline, 1984–2016; the three groups add to 100%

The paper says

A study measured how the world’s muddy coasts (shores of mud, not sand or rock) moved from 1984 to 2016. Its summary says “the majority of the world’s muddy coasts are eroding at rates exceeding 1 m/yr”: the shore retreating over a metre a year.

Its own data show

The paper’s Table 1 sorts all its muddy coastline by how fast the shore moved. Eroding over a metre a year (its four erosion-speed bands added up): 30.5%. Barely moving, under a metre a year either way: 40.3%, the largest group. Growing over a metre a year: 29.2%. The main text agrees: 31%, 40%, 29%.

“The majority” means more than half; 30.5% is under a third. Erosion edges past half only if you ignore the 40.3% that barely moved (30.5 out of the remaining 59.7 is 51.1%), and the summary makes no such exception. Its readers learn that most muddy coasts are retreating; the paper found about as much coast growing as eroding.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

Global distribution and dynamics of muddy coasts · Nat Commun (2023) · doi:10.1038/s41467-023-43819-6