Paperonium

← Back to the plain-language case

Abstract says most muddy coasts erode over 1 m/yr; Table 1 shows 30.5%

Nat Commun (2023) · doi:10.1038/s41467-023-43819-6 · PMC10716179

Summary

The abstract states, and the article's web summary repeats, that "the majority of the world's muddy coasts are eroding at rates exceeding 1 m/yr over the last three decades". The paper's own Table 1 puts 30.5% of muddy coastline in the four erosion classes beyond −1 m/yr, 40.3% in the stable class and 29.2% in the accretion classes. The Results text gives the same split (31%, 40%, 29%) and reports net global accretion of +0.18 m/yr, a gain of 579 km². Eroding coasts are therefore neither a majority nor the largest class. This is one of the two findings the abstract reports, so readers of the abstract alone are told that most muddy coasts are retreating, whereas the paper finds erosion and accretion nearly balanced by length (30.5% vs 29.2%) and a small net gain in area.

What the paper reports

Abstract:

Furthermore, the majority of the world’s muddy coasts are eroding at rates exceeding 1 m/yr over the last three decades.

Web summary (a separate abstract element of type "web-summary" in the archived XML; on nature.com it is the article's description metadata used in search and link previews, not printed on the article page):

14% of the world’s coastlines are muddy and the majority of them are eroding at rates exceeding 1 m per year over the last three decades, according to an automated classification method that identifies global coastlines.

Results, "Dynamics of muddy coasts vs. sandy coasts", second paragraph:

The analysis of coastline dynamics reveals that 40% of the world’s muddy coasts are stable (absolute long-term change rates of <1 m/year over the period 1984–2016); 31% are persistently eroding, while 29% are accreting (Table 1).

On a global scale, the world’s muddy coasts have accreted 0.18 m/year on average over the three decades of the study period, i.e. a total gain of 579 km2 over this period.

Results, same section, first paragraph:

After filtering the muddy coastline transects for a minimum number of historic data points, temporal coverage, potential ice coverage and outliers, 97.7% of the mud coasts remain suitable for further analysis.

Methods, "Dynamic coastline detection":

In addition, the thresholds for accretion and erosion classes have been increased to 1 m/year to focus on the more dynamic muddy shorelines.

Table 1, "Chronic coastline dynamics classification scheme", muddy-coast column (% of muddy coastline): very extreme accretion (>10 m/yr) 8.8; extreme accretion (5 to 10) 5.4; severe accretion (3 to 5) 4.3; intense accretion (1 to 3) 10.7; stable (−1 to 1) 40.3; intense erosion (−1 to −3) 12.2; severe erosion (−3 to −5) 4.8; extreme erosion (−5 to −10) 5.7; very extreme erosion (<−10) 7.8.

What the paper's own numbers show

Method. The abstract's threshold (1 m/yr) is the same as the boundary between the stable class and the erosion and accretion classes in Table 1 and the Methods. So the share of muddy coastline "eroding at rates exceeding 1 m/yr" is the sum of Table 1's four erosion classes. I summed the muddy column by direction, checked that the column totals 100%, bounded the effect of rounding and of the 2.3% of coastline removed by filtering, and computed the one alternative denominator under which erosion is a majority. Every number below is printed by recompute.py.txt.

Quantity Location Reported Recomputed
Muddy coast eroding > 1 m/yr Abstract; web summary "the majority" (> 50%) 30.5% (12.2 + 4.8 + 5.7 + 7.8)
Muddy coast eroding > 1 m/yr Results, "Dynamics of muddy coasts vs. sandy coasts", para. 2 31% 30.5% (agrees)
Muddy coast stable, |rate| < 1 m/yr Results, same section, para. 2; Table 1 40%; 40.3 40.3% (the largest class)
Muddy coast accreting > 1 m/yr Results, same section, para. 2; Table 1 29% 29.2% (8.8 + 5.4 + 4.3 + 10.7)
Muddy column total Table 1 — 100.0%
Eroding share allowing for rounding of the four entries Table 1 — 30.3% to 30.7%
Eroding share if all filtered-out coast (2.3%) were eroding Results, same section, para. 1 97.7% retained at most 32.1%
Changing by > 1 m/yr in either direction Table 1 — 59.7%
Eroding share among coasts changing by > 1 m/yr only Table 1 — 51.1% (30.5 / 59.7)
Accreting minus eroding Table 1 — −1.3 percentage points
Global mean change rate of muddy coasts Results, same section, para. 2 +0.18 m/yr; +579 km² not recomputable from the paper; sign is net accretion

Erosion falls about 20 percentage points short of a majority of all muddy coastline. The only reading that gives a majority is a different denominator, coasts that change by more than 1 m/yr, and even then the majority is 51.1%.

Figure

The abstract says the majority of muddy coasts erode faster than 1 m/yr; the Results text and Table 1 give 31% and 30.5%

Figure 1. The two statements about the same quantity: the share of all muddy coastline eroding faster than 1 m/yr over 1984–2016. Left (orange outline): the abstract's wording, repeated in the web summary used for search and link previews, which implies more than 50%. Right (grey outline): the Results text and the sum of the four erosion classes of Table 1 (blue, recomputed by recompute.py.txt), with the stable and accretion shares from the same table. The quoted text is abridged with ellipses; the full sentences are given above.

Shares of muddy coastline by class on one 0 to 100% axis, with the abstract's claimed range above 50%

Figure 2. Shares of muddy coastline on a single 0–100% axis. Blue dots are recomputed from Table 1; open orange circles are the rounded values in the Results text; the orange bar from 50% to 100% is the range the abstract's "the majority" implies for the top row. The vertical line marks 50%. The fourth row assigns all of the 2.3% of coastline removed by filtering to erosion, the most favourable case for the abstract. The fifth row changes the denominator to coasts that move by more than 1 m/yr in either direction; it is the only quantity that crosses 50%, and the abstract does not state that restriction.

Why it matters

Explanations considered

Status

Suggested correction

Replace the abstract sentence with one that matches Table 1, for example:

Furthermore, over the last three decades about 31% of the world’s muddy coasts eroded at rates exceeding 1 m/yr, 29% accreted at such rates and 40% were stable, with a small net global gain.

and the web summary with, for example:

14% of the world’s coastlines are muddy; about 60% of them changed by more than 1 m per year over the last three decades, with erosion and accretion roughly balanced, according to an automated classification method that identifies global coastlines.