Paperonium

Psychiatry · Hum Brain Mapp · 2023

Key brain-scan result: −0.438. Its printed range: 0.926 to 1.079. A range must contain its result.

Brain-scan result, as printedrange wholly above zero: theopposite sign−0.4380.926 to 1.079should be inside−0.500.511.5no effect
Brain-scanresult, as printedrange whollyabove zero: theopposite sign−0.4380.926 to 1.079should be inside−0.500.511.5no effect

The brain-scan route’s effect, as printed, and its printed range

The paper says

In depressed teenagers, the paper says, losing the ability to enjoy things is linked to attention problems partly through a brain network used for attention. Its brain-scan evidence puts that route’s effect at −0.438, with a range of 0.926 to 1.079.

Its own data show

That range lies wholly above zero, the opposite sign to the result, which sits 1.364 below it. Figure 7’s two steps (lost enjoyment to network, −0.509; network to attention, 0.263) multiply to −0.134, also outside. Figure 7 even labels −0.438 as the direct link, not this route. Nothing printed fits.

A range is the span of values the data allow, so it must contain its own result. Here nothing fits, so readers cannot tell how big this route is, or whether it exists (zero would mean none). It is the title’s only brain-scan support; the other, a brainwave test, is consistent in the text (−0.389, inside its range).

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

Dynamic network characteristics of adolescents with major depressive disorder: Attention network mediates the association between anhedonia and attentional deficit · Hum Brain Mapp (2023) · doi:10.1002/hbm.26474