Paperonium

Neuroscience · PLoS Genet · 2023

Summary: a gene drops in astrocytes (brain support cells). The paper’s own results: it doesn’t.

Astrocytessame as without TDP-43Its own tableno clear fall:591 to 453, maybe chanceThe summarythe gene fellBrain–blood barrierOuter cellsfell: 899 to 363(down 60%)Inner cellsfell: 1,090 to 594(down 46%)
Astrocytessame as without TDP-43Its own tableno clear fall:591 to 453, maybe chanceThe summarythe gene fellBrain–blood barrierOuter cellsfell: 899 to 363 (down 60%)Inner cellsfell: 1,090 to 594 (down 46%)

With TDP-43 added: which way the gene moved in each kind of support cell

The paper says

Forcing support cells in fruit-fly brains to make the protein TDP-43 shortens the flies’ lives. The paper’s summary says TDP-43 also turns down a gene, SF2/SRSF1, in two kinds of support cell: astrocytes, and the outer cells of the barrier between brain and blood.

Its own data show

The paper’s own results say TDP-43 does not turn the gene down in astrocytes. Its table shows clear falls only in the barrier: 60% in the outer cells and 46% in the inner cells, which the summary never names. In astrocytes the gene dips 23%, a change the paper’s test could not tell from chance.

With two or three samples per cell type, a dip can be luck, so the paper’s test counts a fall only if chance would rarely produce it. The paper finds that turning the gene down further helps these flies live longer. Its summary presents this as deepening a fall in astrocytes that its results say does not exist.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

TDP-43 pathology in Drosophila induces glial-cell type specific toxicity that can be ameliorated by knock-down of SF2/SRSF1 · PLoS Genet (2023) · doi:10.1371/journal.pgen.1010973