Paperonium

Stroke · Stroke · 2023

Summary: 1.30 times the risk of stroke or mini-stroke, range 0.10–1.02. That range excludes 1.30.

The paper’s summarylies outside its own rangeThe paper’s results table1.30 lies inside, as it should1.30×0.10 to 1.02should be inside0.662.560.1×0.2×0.5×1×2×5×same risk as those without damage
The paper’ssummarylies outside itsown rangeThe paper’sresults table1.30 lies inside, asit should1.30×0.10 to 1.02should be inside0.662.560.1×0.3×1×3×same risk as thosewithout damage

Times as likely to have a later stroke or mini-stroke, with new brain damage

The paper says

After treatment of a narrowed neck artery, 51 of 162 patients had new spots of damage on brain scans. The paper’s opening summary says they were 1.30 times as likely as the rest to later have a stroke or mini-stroke: uncertainty range 0.10 to 1.02.

Its own data show

The paper’s results table (Table 2) gives the same 1.30, from the same analysis (allowing for age and blood pressure), with a range of 0.66 to 2.56, which contains 1.30. The summary’s top end, 1.02, is at least 0.27 below 1.30, even allowing for rounding. The summary’s range is wrong, not its 1.30.

An uncertainty range spans the values the data can’t rule out, so it must contain the result. Both ranges include 1× (same risk), so the finding of no clear link to stroke survives. But many see only the summary, and its range, read literally, allows at most 1.02 times the risk; the correct one, up to 2.6 times.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

Long-Term Stroke Risk in Patients With New Ischemic Brain Lesions on MRI After Carotid Revascularization · Stroke (2023) · doi:10.1161/STROKEAHA.123.043336