Down syndrome · Cereb Cortex · 2023
Paper: luck produces its brain–IQ link under 1 in 10,000 times. Its data: 1 in 17.
How often luck alone would produce its strongest link, if no real link existed
The paper says
An odd tone among repeated ones triggers a brain-wave response. In 27 adults with Down syndrome, the paper says those whose response comes later tend to have lower IQ, and that luck alone would make a link this strong under 1 time in 10,000.
Its own data show
Its results put that link’s strength at 0.37 (0 is none, 1 is perfect): moderate. With 27 people, luck alone makes a link that strong about 1 time in 17. Its seven other links, each claimed under 1 in 100, come up by luck even more often: 1 in 14 to 1 in 5.
The question behind these numbers: with no real link, how often would luck produce one this strong? In small groups, quite often. Research usually wants under 1 in 20 before calling a link real; this paper chose 1 in 100. None of its eight links passes either, yet they are its only evidence that this brain response measures mental ability.