Paperonium

Cardiology · Eur Heart J · 2023

Summary: 51% vs 7% had heart problems. Only the 51% includes other deaths. Without them: 30%.

Heart damaged by another illness30%Its table, added up: 33 of 109The summary51%Heart problems or any deaththe summary used this row56 of 109No heart damage7%The summaryHeart problems or any death12%834 of 6,7380%204060
Heart damaged by another illness30%Its table, added up33 of 109The summary51%Heart problems or any deaththe summary used this row56 of 109No heart damage7%The summaryHeart problems or any death12%834 of 6,7380%204060

Share with serious heart problems in a year, counted with or without other deaths

The paper says

A study followed patients for a year after surgery. Its summary says 51% of those whose heart was damaged during or soon after surgery by another illness outside the heart, like a severe infection, had serious heart problems, against 7% with no heart damage.

Its own data show

The paper counts as serious heart problems a heart attack, heart failure, a dangerously irregular heartbeat, or death from heart or blood-vessel disease. Its table lists these patients in two columns; added together, 33 of 109 (30%) had one. The summary’s 51% is the 56 of 109 who had one or died of any cause.

A comparison is fair only if both groups are counted the same way. Here only the 51% includes deaths from other causes; with them, the 7% would be 12%. So these patients look about 7 times as likely as undamaged ones to have heart problems; counted the same way, 4 to 4½ times.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

Long-term outcomes of perioperative myocardial infarction/injury after non-cardiac surgery · Eur Heart J (2023) · doi:10.1093/eurheartj/ehac798