Long COVID · Lancet Reg Health Eur · 2023
Summary: not overweight versus severely obese, 4.19 times the odds of breathing better. Its table: 2.78.
Times the odds of breathing better, not overweight versus severely obese
The paper says
The paper’s summary says breathlessness after a COVID-19 hospital stay was likelier to improve between 5 months and 1 year in patients who were not overweight than in severely obese ones: 4.19 times the odds (how many improved for each one who didn’t).
Its own data show
Table 2, which answers that question (990 patients), gives severely obese patients 0.36 times the odds of those not overweight; the other way round, as the summary puts it: 1 ÷ 0.36 = 2.78. The 4.19 is exactly Table 3’s figure: breathlessness new or worse at 1 year than before COVID, in 1,151 patients.
Improving between 5 months and a year, and being worse at a year than before COVID, are different questions asked of different sets of patients. The summary’s six other figures all match Table 2; this one is 51% too big (4.19 ÷ 2.78 = 1.51). Researchers who combine many studies into one answer often take figures from summaries.