Paperonium

← Back to the plain-language case

Abstract reports 15.4% survival before 24 weeks; the paper's own counts give 24.1%

Lancet Reg Health Am (2022) Β· doi:10.1016/j.lana.2022.100330 Β· PMC9903864

Summary

The abstract gives survival to discharge or transfer for US infants born before 24 weeks' gestation in 2007–2018 (N = 77,050) as 15.4%. The Results and Discussion give the same quantity for the same group as 18,533 survivors (24.1%), and 18,533 / 77,050 = 24.05%. That count is supported three more ways inside the paper: the reported deaths, the Table 1 subgroup rows (by sex, race, payer and birth weight, each summing to about 18,533 survivors) and the yearly trend, whose values average about 24%. No count, denominator or subgroup in the paper produces 15.4%. The paper presents these rates as a national benchmark for prenatal counselling, so a reader of the abstract alone would understate survival in this group by 8.7 percentage points (36% in relative terms). None of the paper's trend or regression results depend on the abstract figure.

What the paper reports

Survival rates for infants <24 weeks and with completed 24 weeks were 15.4% and 71.6%, respectively

β€” Abstract, Findings

In the group of infants with GA <24 weeks (N = 77,050), only 18,533 (24.1%) survived

β€” Results, 2nd paragraph (the same sentence goes on: "in infants born with completed 24 weeks of gestation (n = 47,295), a total of 33,872 (71.6%) survived")

mortality among all periviable infants was 71,940 (57.86%)

β€” Results, 1st paragraph (periviable infants: 124,345, "of those, 77,050 infants were born <24 weeks, and 47,295 were born at 24 weeks of gestation")

The study presented the national survival of 24.1% and 71.6% for preterm infants with GA <24 weeks and completed 24 weeks, respectively

β€” Discussion, 1st paragraph

The majority (71.6%) of infants born with GA of 24 weeks survived, whereas only 24.1% of infants <24 weeks survived

β€” Discussion, 2nd paragraph

In infants with GA <24 weeks, survival started at 18.4% in 2007 and was 31.9% by the year 2018

β€” Results, trend paragraph (also in Research in context: "survival of infants born at GA <24 weeks increased from 18.4% to 31.9%")

Female | 34,939 | 9124 (26.1) Male | 41,768 | 9409 (22.5)

β€” Table 1, Gender rows, columns for GA <24 weeks (Total | Alive (%)). The footer says "All numbers represent weighted data."

This study provides national benchmarks that can be used during prenatal counselling

β€” Conclusions

What the paper's own numbers show

Method. I took the counts the paper reports for infants born before 24 weeks (total, survivors, deaths across all periviable infants, and every Table 1 subgroup row) and recomputed the survival percentage in each way the paper's numbers allow. I then looked for any count, denominator or subgroup that would produce 15.4%. As a check against the trend, I read the yearly values off the paper's Figure 1 (upper panel, dotted line) by pixel digitization. This was calibrated on the axis labels and matches the two stated endpoints within 0.2 points. All numbers below are printed by recompute.py.txt.

Quantity Location Reported Recomputed
Survival, GA <24 wk, 2007–2018 Abstract, Findings 15.4% 18,533 / 77,050 = 24.05%
Survival, GA <24 wk, 2007–2018 Results 2nd para; Discussion 1st and 2nd paras 18,533 (24.1%) 24.05% (agrees)
Survival, completed 24 wk Abstract; Results; Discussion 33,872 / 47,295 (71.6%) 71.62% (agrees in all places)
Group sizes Abstract; Results 1st para 77,050 + 47,295; total 124,345 77,050 + 47,295 = 124,345 (agrees)
Mortality, all periviable Results 1st para 71,940 (57.86%) 71,940 / 124,345 = 57.86%. Survivors 124,345 βˆ’ 71,940 = 52,405 = 18,533 + 33,872 exactly, so 52,405 βˆ’ 33,872 = 18,533 survivors <24 wk (24.05%)
Table 1 <24 wk survivors, rows summed Table 1 subgroup counts sex 18,533 / 76,707 = 24.16%; race 18,535 / 77,050 = 24.06%; payer 18,533 / 77,051 = 24.05%; birth weight 18,534 / 77,051 = 24.05%; income 18,202 / 75,830 = 24.00%
Survivors needed for 15.4% derived β€” 0.154 Γ— 77,050 = 11,866 (11,827–11,904 round to 15.4%); no such count appears in the paper
Alternative denominator derived β€” 18,533 / 124,345 (all ≀24 wk) = 14.90%, not 15.4%; 18,533 would need a denominator of 120,344
Ratio of 24-wk to <24-wk survival Abstract vs data 71.6 / 15.4 = 4.65-fold 71.62 / 24.05 = 2.98-fold
Yearly survival, <24 wk Research in context; Results trend para; Discussion 18.4% (2007) to 31.9% (2018) Figure 1 reading (approx.): 18.2, 14.5, 21.0, 20.4, 21.0, 24.6, 24.6, 26.2, 28.7, 29.7, 30.3, 32.0; unweighted mean 24.27%
Pooled 15.4% vs yearly values derived β€” Only 2008 (β‰ˆ14.5%) lies below 15.4%. A pooled 15.4% would need at least (18.2 βˆ’ 15.4) / (18.2 βˆ’ 14.5) = 76% of the 12-year cohort to fall in 2008

Other inconsistencies noted in passing (not part of the main finding, and not needed for it):

Quantity Location Reported Recomputed
Survival by sex, completed 24 wk Table 1 vs Results 2nd para, Abstract and Figure 1 lower panel Female 17,635 / 25,480 (69.2); Male 16,213 / 21,766 (74.5); the text says "Survival among males was lower than females in infants <24 weeks (p < 0.001) and completed 24 weeks (p < 0.001)" 69.2% and 74.5%: the counts and percentages agree, but they show higher crude survival in males, the opposite of the text
Survival by birth weight, completed 24 wk Table 1 vs Results (four-group percentages 45.1% for ≀500 g and 73.8% for >500 g) ≀500 g: 43,772 / 32,283 (45.1); >500 g: 3,523 / 1,590 (73.8) 32,283 / 43,772 = 73.8% and 1,590 / 3,523 = 45.1%: each row's counts give the other row's printed percentage
Median length of stay, survivors Results vs Table 2 text 113 and 114 days; Table 2 118 and 110 days not reconcilable from the reported numbers
Median charges, survivors Results vs Table 2 (and Discussion) text $1,050,953 and $1,016,751; Table 2 (and Discussion) $926,105 and $895,137 not reconcilable from the reported numbers

Figure

Diagram: the abstract's 15.4% set against the Results, Discussion and Table 1, which give 18,533 survivors of 77,050 (24.1%), with the recomputed 24.05% below

Figure 1. The contradiction in the paper's own text. Left: the abstract sentence, with the value at issue (15.4%, orange, as reported). Right: the same quantity elsewhere in the paper: the Results count of 18,533 survivors out of 77,050 (24.1%), the two Discussion statements of 24.1%, the Table 1 survivors by sex (9,124 + 9,409 = 18,533) and the stated trend endpoints. The connector marks that both sides describe the same group (GA <24 weeks, N = 77,050), the same period (2007–2018) and the same outcome (survival to discharge or transfer). Bottom (blue, recomputed): 18,533 / 77,050 = 24.05%. For comparison, 15.4% would require 11,866 survivors, and the nearest alternative denominator (all 124,345 periviable infants) gives 14.90%, which does not round to 15.4%. Values come from the paper or from recompute.py.txt.

Dot plot of survival before 24 weeks: the abstract value at 15.4% against the 24.1% in the Results and six values of about 24% recomputed from the paper's own counts, and the alternative denominator at 14.90%

Figure 2. Survival before 24 weeks on one percentage axis starting at 0. Orange circles are values reported in the paper. Blue diamonds are values recomputed from the paper's own counts: the direct ratio, the route through the reported deaths, and the Table 1 subgroup rows summed by sex, race/ethnicity, payer and birth weight. Every route drawn lands between 24.05% and 24.16% (the income rows, which cover 75,830 of the 77,050 infants and are not drawn, give 24.00%), matching the 24.1% in the Results and Discussion. Only the abstract sits at 15.4%. The bottom row shows that the one plausible alternative denominator gives 14.90%, not 15.4%. The shaded band runs from the reported 2007 value (18.4%) to the reported 2018 value (31.9%). It marks the stated endpoints, not the full yearly range (the paper's Figure 1 shows a lower value, about 14.5%, in 2008). The yearly values themselves are not drawn.

Why it matters

Explanations considered

None of these accounts for 15.4%. The paper's counts, its tables and its trend all support 24.1%.

Status

As of 2026-10-23:

Suggested correction

In the Abstract, Findings, replace "Survival rates for infants <24 weeks and with completed 24 weeks were 15.4% and 71.6%, respectively" with "Survival rates for infants <24 weeks and with completed 24 weeks were 24.1% and 71.6%, respectively", consistent with 18,533 / 77,050 in the Results, Discussion and Table 1. The same correction should be passed to PubMed and other indexes. The authors may also wish to check: