Paperonium

Teen mental health · BMJ Glob Health · 2022

Summary: non-straight teens with HIV clearly more anxious. That’s the all-teens figure; theirs could be chance.

Summary: non-straight teens1.21–4.84: clearly moreTable 1: all 1,247 teens, the verysame numbersTable 2:497 non-straight teensmaybe no gap2.42×0.93 to 4.69×0.7×1×1.5×2×3×5×as often as teens without HIVhigher odds
Summary:non-straight teens1.21–4.84:clearly moreTable 1:all 1,247 teens, thevery same numbersTable 2:497 non-straightteensmaybe no gap2.42×0.934.690.5×1×2×5×as often as teenswithout HIVhigher odds

Teens with HIV versus without: times the odds of high anxiety

The paper says

A study of 1,247 teens in Nigeria, 497 of them not straight. Its summary says that among those 497, teens with HIV had clearly higher odds of high anxiety than those without: 2.42 times as high, with a range of 1.21 to 4.84.

Its own data show

Those exact numbers are the paper’s Table 1 result for all 1,247 teens, 60% of them straight (so are the summary’s other three figures for these teens). Table 2, the 497 non-straight teens alone, gives 2.09, range 0.93 to 4.69. The summary’s own conclusion agrees: no clear difference between non-straight teens with and without HIV.

The range is the span of values the data can’t rule out; a difference counts as clear only if the range leaves out 1 (equal odds). Table 2’s dips to 0.93, so 2.09 can’t be told apart from no difference. The summary, the part most people read, reports a clear result the paper’s own analysis of these teens doesn’t find.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

Associations between mental health and HIV status among sexual minority and heterosexual adolescents in Nigeria · BMJ Glob Health (2022) · doi:10.1136/bmjgh-2022-010231