Paperonium

← Back to the plain-language case

Abstract reverses the omnivore-versus-plant-diet direction for Prevotella, Roseburia and Bacteroides given in the Results

Gut (2021) · doi:10.1136/gutjnl-2021-325168 · PMC9185830

Summary

The abstract states that omnivores had higher Prevotella and Roseburia and lower Bacteroides abundances than vegans and vegetarians. Every other place in the paper that gives these directions gives the opposite one. The Results and Discussion say that P. copri and Roseburia sp. CAG 182 were more abundant in vegetarians and vegans and that B. dorei prevailed in omnivores (Wilcoxon p<0.05, Figure 3A), and Figures 3A and 3C show the same thing: 0 of 13 direction statements outside the abstract agree with it. The abstract is the part of the paper most readers and indexing services see, and it reports the diet–microbiome contrast the wrong way round; the analysis and the paper's other headline results are not affected.

What the paper reports

All quotations were checked verbatim against the PMC-archived text with src/show.py (python recompute.py.txt --verify repeats the check), and against the publisher's typeset PDF (Gut 2022;71:1302–1314).

Abstract, Results paragraph:

In omnivores, higher Prevotella and Roseburia and lower Bacteroides abundances than in vegans and vegetarians were observed.

Abstract, Design paragraph (the population):

dietary recording from 120 healthy volunteers, equally distributed for the different diets and matched for sex and age

Results, section "Gut microbiome composition and functions and relation to faecal miRNAs", first paragraph:

Prevotella copri and Roseburia sp. CAG 182 showed higher abundance in VT/VN compared with O, while Bacteroides dorei (currently Phocaeicola dorei) prevailed in O (p<0.05; figure 3A).

Figure 3 legend, panels A and C:

(A) Box plots showing the relative abundance of three bacterial species differentially prevalent among the dietary groups. *Wilcoxon rank-sum p<0.05.

The colour indicates the dietary group in which the variable has the maximum level.

Discussion, paragraph on the gut microbiome:

the gut microbiome taxonomic composition varied according to the dietary patterns, with P. copri and Roseburia sp. CAG 182, having a higher abundance in VT/VN than O.

Discussion, paragraph on miR-425-3p:

Higher stool levels of miR-425-3p and miR-638 were also significantly correlated with Roseburia and R. bacterium D5, which in our cohort were significantly more abundant in VT/VN

Results, section "Integration of miRNAs, microbiome and diet" (the miRNA–taxon chain that depends on the direction):

Two DEmiRNAs, miR-425-3p and miR-638, attracted our interest since they were associated with a coherent higher expression in VT/VN compared with both the analysed O groups

Consistently, higher levels of Roseburia sp. CAG 182 and R. bacterium D5, as well as a lower abundance of A. colihominis were found in subjects within the highest expression levels of miR-638.

(O, omnivores; VT, vegetarians; VN, vegans.)

What the paper's own numbers show

Method. The paper prints no abundance values, effect sizes or exact p-values for these taxa, only the direction and "p<0.05", so there is nothing numeric to recompute. I instead coded every statement or display in the paper that says which diet group has more of a Prevotella, Roseburia or Bacteroides taxon as "higher in O" or "lower in O" and compared it with the abstract. The text statements come from the Results and Discussion. The figure entries were read from the archived Figure 3 image (Europe PMC, gutjnl-2021-325168f03.jpg). In panel A I used the box positions and the significance marks; in panel C I used the bar colour, which by the legend marks the group with the highest level (red O, green VN). recompute.py.txt holds the ledger and prints every count below.

Quantity Location Reported (abstract) What the rest of the paper shows
Prevotella direction Results p1 (P. copri); Discussion; Fig. 3A higher in O lower in O: higher in VT/VN, O vs VT and O vs VN marked p<0.05 (0 of 3 agree)
Roseburia direction Results p1 and Discussion (sp. CAG 182); Discussion (genus); Fig. 3A (sp. CAG 182); Fig. 3C (sp. CAG 182, R. hominis) higher in O lower in O: highest in VN, O vs VN marked p<0.05; both Fig. 3C bars coloured VN (0 of 6 agree)
Bacteroides direction Results p1 (B. dorei); Fig. 3A (B. dorei); Fig. 3C (B. finegoldii, B. massiliensis) lower in O higher in O: B. dorei "prevailed in O", O vs VN marked p<0.05; both Fig. 3C bars coloured O (0 of 4 agree)
All direction statements text (6) and figures (7) — 0 of 13 agree with the abstract
Indirect check Results, "Integration..." — miR-425-3p and miR-638 are higher in VT/VN, and high levels go with more Roseburia sp. CAG 182; this fits Roseburia higher in VT/VN, not in O
Correction or erratum Crossref, PMC, Europe PMC, PubMed — none found

The thirteen entries are not thirteen independent analyses. The Results sentence, the Discussion and Figure 3A all describe the same Wilcoxon comparison, and Figure 3C is a separate (DIABLO) view of the same subjects. The point of the count is that the body of the paper is internally consistent and the abstract sentence is the only exception.

Figure

The abstract and the Results describe the same omnivore-versus-plant-diet comparison with all three taxon directions reversed

Figure 1. Top: the abstract sentence (orange) and the Results sentence it summarises (blue), both verbatim; they describe the same comparison of omnivores with vegetarians and vegans among the 120 subjects. Bottom: the direction for each genus as the abstract gives it (orange) and as the Results, Discussion and Figure 3A/3C give it (blue). The right-hand column counts how many of the paper's own statements and displays agree with the abstract for each genus (0 of 3, 0 of 6, 0 of 4; 0 of 13 in total, from recompute.py.txt). The figure shows no data values, because the paper reports none for these taxa.

Why it matters

Explanations considered

Status

Suggested correction

In the Results paragraph of the abstract, replace

In omnivores, higher Prevotella and Roseburia and lower Bacteroides abundances than in vegans and vegetarians were observed.

with

In omnivores, lower Prevotella and Roseburia and higher Bacteroides abundances than in vegans and vegetarians were observed.

or, to match the species-level wording of the Results, "In vegans and vegetarians, higher Prevotella copri and Roseburia sp. CAG 182 and lower Bacteroides dorei abundances than in omnivores were observed." No change to the Results, Discussion, figures or conclusions is needed.