Paperonium

← Back to the plain-language case

The 2019 overall adolescent YLL is 11 494 below boys plus girls, understating the five-year total

JAMA Pediatr (2022) · doi:10.1001/jamapediatrics.2021.6032 · PMC8804970

Summary

The paper's single Table gives years of life lost (YLL) to unintentional drug overdose by year and sex. For adolescents (10-19 years) in 2019 it prints an overall YLL of 27 919.85, but the boys and girls cells in the same row add up to 26 711.99 + 12 701.86 = 39 413.85. In the other nine year-rows of the Table, the overall cell equals boys plus girls to the cent. The adolescent five-year total of 187 077.92, printed in the Total row and in the Results, is the sum of the overall column with the 2019 cell as printed. The paper's own boys and girls totals add up to 198 571.92, and its stated annual mean (SD) of 39 714.38 (2689.63) and its Discussion figure of "nearly 200 000 YLL" both match 198 571.92, not 187 077.92. The stated adolescent total is therefore 11 494.00 YLL (5.8%) too low, and the printed 2019 cell shows a 24.6% fall in adolescent YLL from 2018 to 2019 where the paper's own sex-specific numbers show a 6.4% rise. The paper's conclusions do not change.

What the paper reports

Table, "Annual Mortality Due to Unintentional Drug Overdose Among Adolescents and Young People, 2015-2019", adolescents section. Columns are Year | Boys/men deaths, No. | Boys/men YLL | Girls/women deaths, No. | Girls/women YLL | Overall deaths, No. | Overall YLL:

2018 | 407 | 23 910.59 | 207 | 13 117.02 | 614 | 37 027.61
2019 | 455 | 26 711.99 | 199 | 12 701.86 | 654 | 27 919.85
Total | 2267 | 133 023.64 | 1029 | 65 548.28 | 3296 | 187 077.92

Table footer (the only footnote):

Abbreviation: YLL, years of life lost.

Methods:

YLL were calculated as standard life expectancy minus age at death. Male and female life expectancy at each individual age was determined from the 2017 Social Security Administration Period Life Table.

Results, first paragraph:

Male adolescents outnumbered female adolescents in incident deaths (2267 [68.8%] vs 1029 [31.2%]) and YLL (133 023.64 vs 65 548.28). Annual total YLL due to unintentional drug overdose was stably elevated with a mean (SD) 39 714.38 (2689.63) annual YLL (Table). Adolescents experienced a total of 187 077.92 YLL during the study period.

Results, second paragraph:

Young people experienced a total of 1 227 223.58 YLL during the 5-year period of study.

Discussion, first sentence:

Over the 5-year period of this cross-sectional study, adolescents experienced nearly 200 000 YLL, and young people amassed greater than 1.25 million YLL.

What the paper's own numbers show

Method. YLL and deaths are counts summed over decedents, so for each year the overall cell should equal the boys/men cell plus the girls/women cell. I checked this for every year-row of both age groups, summed every column and compared it with the printed Total row, and recomputed the annual mean and SD of the adolescent overall YLL series two ways: from the overall column as printed, and from boys plus girls in each row. I also computed YLL per death for each adolescent year as a check on scale. All inputs are copied from the Table and text. Every number below is printed by recompute.py.txt.

Quantity Location Reported Recomputed from the paper's own numbers
Adolescent overall YLL, 2019 Table, 2019 row, Overall YLL 27 919.85 39 413.85 (26 711.99 + 12 701.86); printed cell is 11 494.00 lower
Adolescent overall YLL, 2015-2018 Table, Overall YLL 38 464.60; 44 187.60; 39 478.26; 37 027.61 identical to boys + girls (difference 0.00 in each year)
Adolescent overall deaths, 2019 Table, 2019 row 654 654 (455 + 199)
Adolescent five-year total YLL Table Total row; Results 187 077.92 198 571.92 (133 023.64 + 65 548.28); 187 077.92 is the sum of the printed overall column, including the 2019 cell
Boys and girls total YLL Table Total row; Results 133 023.64; 65 548.28 133 023.64; 65 548.28 (column sums agree)
Annual mean (SD) of adolescent YLL Results 39 714.38 (2689.63) 39 714.38 (2689.63) from boys + girls per year (sample SD); 37 415.58 (5948.42) from the printed column
Adolescent total, Discussion Discussion "nearly 200 000 YLL" 198 571.92 is 99.3% of 200 000; 187 077.92 is 93.5%
Change in adolescent YLL, 2018 to 2019 Table 37 027.61 to 27 919.85 (implied −24.6%) 37 027.61 to 39 413.85 (+6.4%)
Adolescent YLL per death, 2019 Table 27 919.85 / 654 = 42.69 39 413.85 / 654 = 60.27; other years 60.29, 60.20, 60.18, 60.31
Young people, every year and Total Table, young people section e.g. 2019: 236 273.30; Total 1 227 223.58 all match men + women and the column sums
Male share of deaths Results 68.8% vs 31.2% (adolescents); 71.9% vs 28.1% (young people) 68.8% vs 31.2%; 71.9% vs 28.1%

The Table is internally consistent everywhere except one cell. Every other row adds across, every column adds down to its Total, and the death counts in the 2019 row add correctly. The 2019 adolescent overall YLL is the only exception. Two further checks in the paper's own text favor 39 413.85 over the printed value. The Results give an annual mean and SD that reproduce to the cent only from the boys-plus-girls series (39 714.38 × 5 = 198 571.90), and the YLL per death in 2019 is about 60.3 with the boys-plus-girls value, as in every other year, but 42.7 with the printed value. The difference between the printed and recomputed cells is a whole number, 11 494.00, and the two values share the decimals .85.

Figure

The printed 2019 overall adolescent YLL drops away from boys plus girls; the other four years coincide

Figure 1. Adolescent (10-19 years) unintentional overdose YLL by year, on an axis starting at zero. Blue filled circles and solid line: boys YLL plus girls YLL in each row of the Table, recomputed. Orange open circles and dashed line: the Overall YLL column as printed. From 2015 to 2018 the two series are identical to the cent, so the markers overlap. In 2019 the printed cell is 27 919.85 and boys plus girls is 39 413.85, a gap of 11 494.00 YLL. Read at face value, the printed column shows a fall of 24.6% from 2018 to 2019; the paper's sex-specific cells show a rise of 6.4%. All values are from the Table or from recompute.py.txt.

Two routes from the Table to the five-year total and annual mean; only the boys-plus-girls route reproduces the mean and SD stated in the Results

Figure 2. Calculation flow. Left (orange): starting from the Overall YLL column as printed, the five-year sum is 187 077.92, which is the total in the Table and the Results, and the annual mean (SD) is 37 415.58 (5948.42). Right (blue): replacing the 2019 cell by boys plus girls (39 413.85), the five-year sum is 198 571.92, equal to the printed boys total plus the printed girls total, and the annual mean (SD) is 39 714.38 (2689.63), exactly the values in the Results. The Discussion's "nearly 200 000 YLL" also fits the right-hand total. The paper's stated total and its stated mean therefore come from different versions of the 2019 cell.

Why it matters

Explanations considered

Status

Suggested correction

In the Table, adolescents section, change the 2019 Overall YLL from

27 919.85

to

39 413.85

and the Total row Overall YLL from

187 077.92

to

198 571.92

In the Results, change

Adolescents experienced a total of 187 077.92 YLL during the study period.

to

Adolescents experienced a total of 198 571.92 YLL during the study period.

These values follow from the paper's own sex-specific cells and agree with its stated mean (SD) and with the Discussion. The authors may wish to confirm the 2019 value against their source data. They may also wish to check the Discussion's "greater than 1.25 million YLL" for young people against the 1 227 223.58 YLL in the Table and Results, for example by changing it to "more than 1.2 million YLL".