Paperonium

← Back to the plain-language case

Combined odds ratio interval for HLA-C variant rs114598080 is incompatible with its p-value and components

PLoS Pathog (2020) Β· doi:10.1371/journal.ppat.1008565 Β· PMC7259797

Summary

The abstract, the Results text and Table 2 report the combined association of rs114598080 with leprosy as OR = 1.47 [1.46–1.48] with p = 8.77x10-13. An interval that narrow implies a test statistic of about z = 111 (about 75.5 under the interval convention the other rows of Table 2 follow, and no less than about 50 at any rounding), while p = 8.77x10-13 implies z = 7.15 and an interval of about [1.32–1.63]. The combined OR of 1.47 also lies below both of its components (discovery 1.85, replication 2.06). Pooling those two components gives about 1.97 [1.65–2.36], with p β‰ˆ 6x10-14, close to the printed p-value. rs114598080 is one of the three independent HLA signals the abstract highlights. As printed, its effect size is probably too low and its precision is overstated about 10–15-fold in standard error (roughly 110–240 times in statistical information), depending on the interval convention.

What the paper reports

Abstract:

We identified three independently associated SNPs, two located in the HLA class I region (rs1265048: OR = 0.69 [0.58–0.80], combined p-value = 5.53x10-11; and rs114598080: OR = 1.47 [1.46–1.48], combined p-value = 8.77x10-13), and one located in the HLA class II region (rs3187964 (OR = 1.67 [1.55–1.80], combined p-value = 8.35x10-16).

Results, "Replication study > Within the MHC region", third paragraph:

The rs114598080 SNP, located in a CTCF binding site (ENSR00000262841) 15.6 kb upstream of the HLA-C gene, gave a univariate p-value of 8.8x10-13 in the combined analysis, with an OR for developing leprosy for AG vs. GG (or AA vs. AG) of 1.47 [1.46–1.48].

Table 2, row rs114598080. The columns are: SNP, m/M, gene, MAF, then P value and OR [95% CI] for the discovery GWAS, the replication (one-tailed, "#") and the combined GWAS and replication sample:

rs114598080 (6:31255442) | A/G | HLA-C | 0.10 | 3.90x10-06 | 1.85 [1.39–2.44] | 4.39x10-11 | 2.06 [1.7 –Inf] | 8.77x10-13 | 1.47 [1.46–1.48]

Table 2 footer (excerpt):

* with respect to the minor allele# one-tailed test

Materials and methods, "Statistical methods", first paragraph, on the combined analysis:

Conditional logistic regression was also used for a combined analysis of the discovery family and replication case-control samples. In this combined analysis, all cases and controls from the case-control study were grouped together in a stratum for analysis, in combination with the strata consisting of the affected offspring and their pseudosibs, as previously described [34, 35].

Results, same section, second paragraph, on the multivariable model:

We found that three SNPs (rs3187964, rs114598080 and rs1265048) were required to capture the full association signal in the HLA region (S7 Table).

The strength of association was much lower for rs114598080 (multivariable p-value = 3.75x10-5), and even lower for rs1265048, (multivariable p-value = 0.011).

What the paper's own numbers show

Method. For a Wald estimate, the 95% interval and the p-value both follow from the same standard error of the log OR. So each can be recovered from the other:

The other four combined rows of Table 2 have intervals that are symmetric on the OR scale (for example 0.69 [0.58–0.80]). Read as OR Β± 1.96Β·SE(log OR), they reproduce each row's printed p-value to within rounding. I therefore apply both the standard log-scale reading and this reading to rs114598080. Separately, I pool the SNP's discovery and replication estimates by inverse variance. Their SEs come from their printed intervals; the replication interval is a one-sided 95% bound, so its SE is (ln 2.06 βˆ’ ln 1.7) / 1.645. Every number below is printed by recompute.py.txt.

Quantity Location Reported Recomputed
rs114598080 combined OR [95% CI] Abstract; Results; Table 2 1.47 [1.46–1.48] β€”
rs114598080 combined p Abstract and Table 2 (8.77x10-13); Results (8.8x10-13) 8.77x10-13 β€”
SE(log OR) implied by the CI, log scale from Table 2 β€” 0.00347 β†’ z = 111.0, p β‰ˆ 10^-2678
Same log-scale reading, at the widest rounding [1.455–1.485] from Table 2 β€” SE 0.00521 β†’ z = 74.0, p β‰ˆ 10^-1191
Same, under the other rows' OR Β± 1.96Β·SE reading from Table 2 β€” SE 0.0051 β†’ z = 75.5, p β‰ˆ 10^-1240
Same reading, at the widest rounding [1.455–1.485] from Table 2 β€” SE 0.00765 β†’ z = 50.3 at OR 1.47 (49.9 at OR 1.465), p β‰ˆ 10^-542
z and SE implied by the reported p from Table 2 p = 8.77x10-13 z = 7.15, SE = 0.0539: 15.5x the interval's SE under the log-scale reading (241x less information), 10.6x under the OR Β± 1.96Β·SE reading (112x), 7.0x at that reading's widest rounding (50x)
95% CI implied by the reported p, at OR 1.47 from Table 2 [1.46–1.48] [1.32–1.63] log scale; [1.36–1.58] under the OR Β± 1.96Β·SE reading
Other four combined rows: |z| from p vs from CI (OR Β± 1.96Β·SE reading) Table 2 β€” 6.56 vs 6.61; 8.05 vs 8.04; 7.53 vs 7.46; 5.41 vs 5.36 (all agree)
Combined OR relative to its components Table 2 1.47 vs discovery 1.85, replication 2.06 outside both; the other four rows lie between their components
Discovery component Table 2 1.85 [1.39–2.44], p 3.90x10-06 SE 0.1435, z 4.29
Replication component (one-sided bound) Table 2 2.06 [1.7–Inf], one-tailed p 4.39x10-11 SE 0.1168, z 6.19
Inverse-variance pool of the two components from Table 2 β€” OR 1.97 [1.65–2.36], SE 0.0906, z 7.51, p β‰ˆ 6.1x10-14
Same, with the bound "1.7" read as 1.65 or 1.75 from Table 2 β€” 1.96 [1.62–2.37], p 8x10-12; 1.99 [1.70–2.33], p 3.4x10-17
SE implied by the reported p if the OR were 1.97 from Table 2 β€” 0.0951 (pooled component SE 0.0906)
Rough allelic SE from sample size: 1803 cases, ≀ 2534 controls + pseudosibs Abstract; Methods; MAF from Table 2 (0.10) or S5 Table (0.13) β€” 0.073 (MAF 0.10) or 0.065 (MAF 0.13); an SE of 0.0035 would need a sample about 350–440x larger

Three things follow:

  1. The printed interval and the printed p-value cannot both be right. No rounding or interval convention brings the interval's z below about 50, and the p-value's z is 7.15.
  2. The printed OR of 1.47 cannot be a pooled estimate of 1.85 and 2.06. A common-OR likelihood that is the sum of the two parts has its maximum between the maxima of the two parts. All four other rows of Table 2 behave this way.
  3. The printed p-value fits the pooled components. Pooling gives z = 7.51 (p β‰ˆ 6x10-14), against z = 7.15 printed. At an OR near 1.97, the printed p implies an SE of 0.095, close to the pooled SE of 0.091. This suggests that the p-value is correct and that the OR and its interval are not, although only the original model output can show which value is wrong.

Figure

Dot-and-interval plot of the rs114598080 odds ratios on one log axis: the printed combined interval 1.46–1.48 is a near-point, outside both component estimates, while the interval implied by the printed p and the pooled components are both much wider

Figure 1. Odds ratios for rs114598080 on one log-scale axis; the thin vertical line marks OR = 1. Orange values are printed in Table 2: discovery 1.85 [1.39–2.44], replication 2.06 with a one-sided 95% lower bound of 1.7 (arrow = open upper end), and the combined estimate 1.47 [1.46–1.48], whose interval is barely wider than its marker. Blue values are recomputed from Table 2's own numbers by recompute.py.txt. The first is the 95% interval that the printed p = 8.77x10-13 implies around the printed OR, [1.32–1.63]. The second is the inverse-variance pool of the two printed components, 1.97 [1.65–2.36]. The printed combined estimate lies below both component point estimates, and its SE is about 10–15 times smaller than its own p-value allows (15.5x under a log-scale reading of the interval, 10.6x under the OR Β± 1.96Β·SE reading the other rows follow).

For each of the five combined rows of Table 2, |z| implied by the printed p-value and |z| implied by the printed CI; four rows agree closely, rs114598080 shows 7.15 versus 75.5

Figure 2. For each combined row of Table 2, the test statistic |z| implied by the printed combined p-value (orange ring) and by the printed combined interval read as OR Β± 1.96Β·SE(log OR) (blue diamond), on a log axis. For four SNPs the two agree to within 0.07, so this reading of the intervals is consistent with the table. For rs114598080 the p-value gives 7.15 and the interval gives 75.5 (111 under a standard log-scale reading). All values are computed by recompute.py.txt from Table 2.

Why it matters

Explanations considered

Status

As of 2026-10-24:

Sources: PLOS article, PMC7259797, medRxiv preprint, Crossref REST API (relation.object and update records for the DOI).

Suggested correction

The authors would need to re-extract the combined conditional logistic regression output for rs114598080 and correct the OR and 95% CI in three places: the abstract, Table 2 (combined columns) and the Results text ("1.47 [1.46–1.48]"). They should also confirm the p-value of 8.77x10-13, which is consistent with the component estimates. Based on the paper's own numbers, the corrected estimate is expected near OR 1.9–2.0, with a 95% interval on the order of [1.65–2.36], rather than [1.46–1.48]. If the OR of 1.47 is in fact correct, the interval implied by the printed p-value would be about [1.32–1.63].

The same table has a second, smaller slip. The discovery interval for rs1265048 is printed as 0.63 [0.52–0.63], with the upper limit equal to the estimate, in both Table 2 and S7 Table. The printed p = 8.72x10-06 implies about [0.51–0.77], so the upper limit is probably about 0.76–0.77.