Paperonium

← Back to the plain-language case

The abstract reverses the direction of the paper's hypoxia result

PLoS Pathog (2019) Β· doi:10.1371/journal.ppat.1007745 Β· PMC6513112

Summary

The paper reports that STAT2-dependent type I interferon signaling oxygenates the infected gut, so that removing STAT2 restores hypoxia. Its abstract, however, states that the gut tissue of Stat2−/− mice showed "decreased hypoxia," while the Results, the author summary, the Discussion and the paper's own mechanistic thesis all state the opposite: Stat2−/− tissue was more hypoxic (higher pimonidazole staining, lower oxygenation) than wild-type. Fig 6F is a qualitative immunohistochemistry image with no reported staining intensities or statistics, so there is no number to recompute; what can be checked is that one sentence assigns the reverse direction to the same comparison that four other passages describe. Because the abstract is the most-read and most-indexed part of a paper, a reader who takes this result from the abstract alone records the direction backwards, even though the body and the main conclusions are correct and unchanged.

What the paper reports

Here, we show that STAT2 dependent type I IFN signaling contributes to the inflammatory environment by disrupting hypoxia enabling the pathogenic S. Typhimurium to outgrow the microbiota.

β€” Abstract (opening; the mechanism: type I IFN removes hypoxia in wild-type mice)

Although inflammatory pathology was similar between wild-type and Stat2−/− mice, we observed decreased hypoxia in the gut tissue of Stat2−/− mice.

β€” Abstract (the sentence in question: Stat2−/− = less hypoxic)

We determined that the intestinal environment in Stat2−/− mice was more hypoxic than in wild-type mice as shown by higher levels of pimonidazole staining (red) (Fig 6F). Both wild-type and Stat2−/− mice showed comparable hypoxia staining without infection (S3B Fig).

β€” Results, "Neutrophil-associated oxygenation contributes to low bacterial burdens" (Stat2−/− = more hypoxic)

In the absence of STAT2-dependent type I IFN, production of neutrophil reactive oxygen species was impaired, and epithelial metabolism returned to homeostatic hypoxia.

β€” Author summary (loss of STAT2 restores hypoxia, i.e. more hypoxic)

The competition experiments between wild-type S. Typhimurium and cyxA mutant as well as hypoxia staining confirmed that oxygenation of the gut lumen of Stat2−/− mice was lower compared to that of wild-type mice.

β€” Discussion, paragraph 1 (lower oxygenation = more hypoxic)

It was previously reported that hypoxia decreases in the intestine during S. Typhimurium infection [45].

β€” Results (the baseline biology: infection removes hypoxia; retaining hypoxia is the Stat2−/− phenotype)

One hour prior to euthanasia, wild-type and Stat2−/− infected mice were injected with 100 mg/kg of PMDZ … [PMDZ is] a marker of hypoxia.

β€” Materials and methods, "Hypoxia staining"; Results (pimonidazole is a hypoxia probe: higher signal = more hypoxia)

What the paper's own numbers show

Method. This is a text-versus-text contradiction, not an arithmetic slip. Fig 6F reports pimonidazole immunohistochemistry images; the paper gives no staining intensities, group means or statistics for the wild-type versus Stat2−/− comparison, so there is no value to re-add. What is objectively checkable is (i) the direction each section assigns to the same headline comparison β€” gut-tissue hypoxia in Stat2−/− versus wild-type, infected animals, Fig 6F β€” and whether those directions agree; (ii) that the probe runs in the direction the argument assumes (pimonidazole adducts form only at low O₂, so higher staining means more hypoxia, as the Methods state); and (iii) that the pimonidazole dose, stated two ways, is internally consistent and so is not the source of the discrepancy. Direction is encoded as +1 (Stat2−/− more hypoxic) or −1 (Stat2−/− less hypoxic). Every value below is printed by recompute.py.txt.

Quantity Location Reported Recomputed from the paper's own statements
Hypoxia direction, Stat2−/− vs WT Abstract "decreased hypoxia in Stat2−/−" direction −1 (less hypoxic)
Hypoxia direction, Stat2−/− vs WT Results; Fig 6F "more hypoxic … higher pimonidazole staining" direction +1 (more hypoxic)
Hypoxia direction, Stat2−/− vs WT Author summary "returned to homeostatic hypoxia" direction +1 (more hypoxic)
Hypoxia direction, Stat2−/− vs WT Discussion, para 1 oxygenation "lower" in Stat2−/− direction +1 (more hypoxic)
Hypoxia direction, Stat2−/− vs WT Title / thesis IFN oxygenates gut; absence restores hypoxia direction +1 (more hypoxic)
Four non-abstract sections agree with each other cross-section β€” True (shared value +1)
Abstract matches the rest of the paper cross-section β€” False (abstract −1 vs others +1)
Pimonidazole dose Results 2.0 mg / 20 g body weight 100.0 mg/kg
Pimonidazole dose Methods 100 mg/kg 100.0 mg/kg β€” consistent
Uninfected baseline (WT vs Stat2−/−) Results; S3B Fig "comparable hypoxia staining" no baseline difference that could flip the infected sign

Figure

Two text panels holding the conflicting excerpts from the abstract and the Results, joined by a connector labelled "direction reversed"; a key states that orange is the abstract's direction and blue the direction printed in the rest of the paper.

Figure 1. The left panel holds the abstract's sentence and the direction it states (Stat2−/− less hypoxic than wild-type); the right panel holds the Results sentence describing the same Fig 6F pimonidazole comparison and its direction (Stat2−/− more hypoxic), which the Discussion, author summary and thesis share. The two directions are opposite, as the labelled connector marks. Orange marks the direction as printed in the abstract and blue the direction printed everywhere else, so the contrast never rests on colour alone. Because pimonidazole marks hypoxia (higher staining = more hypoxic) and the uninfected controls in S3B Fig were comparable, no change of probe direction or baseline reconciles the two sentences.

Why it matters

Explanations considered

Status

As of 2026-10-24:

Suggested correction

In the abstract, change the one sentence so its direction matches the Results, Discussion, author summary and the abstract's own framing, for example:

Although inflammatory pathology was similar between wild-type and Stat2−/− mice, we observed increased hypoxia in the gut tissue of Stat2−/− mice.

No change to the figures, Methods or conclusions appears to be needed; the correction removes an internal contradiction rather than altering any finding.