Paperonium

← Back to the plain-language case

Adult–child FP–salience difference called significant after FDR, but Table 3 gives P = 0.130

Cereb Cortex (2026) ¡ doi:10.1093/cercor/bhag167 ¡ PMC13641069

Summary

This fMRI study compares functional connectivity in 15 children and 16 adults during a conversation with ChatGPT. The Abstract names FP–salience as one of the two main between-network couplings that are stronger in adults, and the Results say that the FP–salience and FP–DAN findings "remained significant" after Benjamini–Hochberg FDR correction at q = .05. The paper's own Table 3 reports the FP–salience group effect as F(1,27) = 2.434, P = 0.130, which is not significant even before correction, and the table does not mark that row as significant. Recomputing the test from the printed F reproduces P = 0.130. A Benjamini–Hochberg correction over the 21 between-network tests leaves only FP–DAN significant (adjusted p = 0.024), with FP–salience at 0.228. The adult-greater FP–salience coupling in the Abstract therefore has no statistical support in the paper's reported analysis.

What the paper reports

Abstract:

Adults showed stronger within-network connectivity in control/attention systems, most robustly in FP, with additional effects in salience and DAN. Adults also exhibited greater cross-network integration, particularly FP-salience and FP-DAN couplings, alongside broader adult-greater effects among memory- and attention-related pairs.

Abstract, final sentence:

This highlights FP-centric pathways and their salience-gated interactions as candidate substrates by which creativity supports goal-directed co-creative dialog with AI.

Results, "Neuroimaging measures", between-networks analysis, third paragraph:

Overall, these results suggest a broader and more integrated pattern of between-networks connectivity in adults relative to children, particularly involving the FP, DAN,VAN, memory, and salience systems. After correcting for multiple comparisons (FDR correction (Benjamini and Hochberg 1995), Benjamini–Hochberg, q = .05), the results for the FP-salience and FP-DAN findings remained significant (Table 3). See also Fig. 2.

Results, between-networks analysis, second paragraph (the last of the pairs the text lists as significant; FP–salience is not among them):

Finally, significant group effects were found for connectivity between the FP-VAN, F(1,27) = 5.820, P = 0.023, Ρ2P = .177, and FP-DAN, F(1,27) = 13.252, P = 0.001, Ρ2P = .329, with adults again showing higher connectivity.

Table 3 ("Between networks, functional connectivity of EF, attention, and sensory after controlling for FD"), FP–Salience row, and the table footnote:

FP–Salience | 0.138 ± 0.040 | 0.180 ± 0.060 | F = 2.434, P = 0.130, η2P = .083 | A > C

Bold represents significant results.

Methods, "Statistical analyses":

a multivariate analysis of variance (MANOVA) was conducted with group (children, adults) as a between-subjects factor and framewise displacement (FD) as a covariate to control for head motion.

Results, "Moderation results" (a different test on the same pair):

Specifically, significant moderation effects emerged for the FP–Salience, F(1,26) = 5.869, P = 0.023, partial η2P = .184, and Salience–VAN, F(1,26) = 4.575, P = 0.042, partial η2P = .150, pairs, indicating that the relationship between creativity and connectivity strength differed between children and adults for these networks.

Discussion:

Children also demonstrated reduced functional connectivity between the selected cognitive networks (FP-salience, FP-DAN, DMN-memory).

Results, "Power analysis":

Our achieved sample (children, n = 15; adults, n = 16) is therefore well-powered for large effects, consistent with prior literature, but underpowered for moderate effects, guiding the interpretation of null or small effects accordingly.

What the paper's own numbers show

Method. Each row of Table 3 is a group effect with one numerator degree of freedom, so P = Pr(F(1, 27) ≥ F) and partial η² = F / (F + 27). I recomputed both from the printed F for all 21 between-network pairs and compared them with the printed values. I then applied the Benjamini–Hochberg step-up procedure at q = .05, the correction the paper names, to the 21 between-network P values (the family of Table 3). The adjusted p for the test ranked i of m is the minimum over j ≥ i of m·p(j)/j. I repeated the correction with the printed P values, with the 7 within-network tests of Table 2 as their own family, and with all 28 tests pooled. Individual-level data are not available, so the ANCOVA itself cannot be refitted. Every number below is printed by recompute.py.txt.

Quantity Location Reported Recomputed from the paper's numbers
FP–salience group effect, P Table 3 F(1,27) = 2.434, P = 0.130 P = 0.130 (0.1304); not significant before correction
FP–salience partial η² Table 3 .083 2.434 / 29.434 = 0.083
FP–salience, one-sided P derived – 0.065, still above .05
FP–salience after BH, 21 between-network tests Results ("remained significant"); Abstract significant at q = .05 rank 12 of 21, critical value 0.0286, adjusted p = 0.228
FP–salience after BH, printed P values derived – 21 × 0.130 / 12 = 0.228
FP–salience after BH, 28 tests pooled derived – adjusted p = 0.243
FP–salience after BH, any family size derived – a BH-adjusted p is never below the raw p, so P = 0.130 fails for every family
FP–DAN group effect, P Table 3; Results P < 0.001 (Table 3); P = 0.001 (Results) 0.0011
FP–DAN after BH, 21 tests Results ("remained significant") significant adjusted p = 0.024: significant, the only pair that is
Next-smallest BH-adjusted p (CO–salience and seven others) derived – 0.062; no other between-network pair survives
DMN–memory Table 3; Discussion P = 0.017, listed among reduced couplings adjusted p = 0.062
Agreement of all printed P and η² with their F Table 3 21 rows all 21 within rounding of F (CO–DMN: F = 0.006 gives 0.936–0.941, printed 0.937)
Rows printed in bold Table 3 (publisher XML) 9 bold rows exactly the 9 rows with P < .05; FP–salience not bold
Within-FP group effect after BH, 7 within-network tests Table 2; Results ("the FP findings remained significant") significant P = 0.006, adjusted p = 0.044: significant
Within-salience and within-DAN after BH, 7 tests Table 2; Abstract ("additional effects") P = 0.025, 0.027 adjusted p = 0.062 each
FP–salience group × creativity interaction Results, Moderation F(1,26) = 5.869, P = 0.023, η² = .184 P = 0.023, η² = 0.184; a test of slopes, not of group means

The table is internally consistent. Every printed P and η² follows from its F, and the bold marking matches uncorrected P < .05. The only statement that the numbers do not support is the sentence saying FP–salience "remained significant" after FDR, and the Abstract and Discussion statements that rest on it.

Figure

Printed P values and recomputed Benjamini–Hochberg adjusted p values for the 21 between-network tests

Figure 1. For each of the 21 between-network pairs in Table 3, the orange dot is the uncorrected P printed in the table and the blue diamond is the Benjamini–Hochberg adjusted p recomputed over the 21 tests from the printed F(1,27) values. Pairs are ordered by P. The axis is logarithmic and the dashed line marks q = .05. FP–DAN is printed as P < 0.001 and drawn at 0.001 (left-pointing marker); its recomputed P is 0.0011. Only FP–DAN has an adjusted p below .05 (0.024). FP–salience, which the Results describe as remaining significant after FDR, has a printed P of 0.130 and an adjusted p of 0.228, the twelfth of 21. Eight pairs with uncorrected P between 0.008 and 0.026 share an adjusted p of 0.062.

The conflicting statements in the text and in Table 3

Figure 2. The Abstract and the Results text (left) present FP–salience, together with FP–DAN, as a significant adult-greater coupling after Benjamini–Hochberg correction. The Table 3 row the text cites (right) gives F = 2.434, P = 0.130 before any correction, and the row is not bold, although the footnote says bold marks significant results. Recomputing from F(1,27) = 2.434 gives the same P and η², and a BH-adjusted p of 0.228.

Why it matters

FP–salience is one of the two between-network couplings that the Abstract names as greater in adults, and the Abstract's closing sentence builds on it ("FP-centric pathways and their salience-gated interactions"). The Discussion lists it first among the couplings that are reduced in children. A reader of the Abstract would take it as a corrected, significant group difference. The paper's own test gives P = 0.130 for that difference, and after the correction the paper describes, only FP–DAN remains among the 21 between-network pairs.

The paper's main conclusion does not depend on this result alone. The within-FP group difference (P = 0.006, BH-adjusted 0.044 across the 7 within-network tests) and the FP–DAN coupling (adjusted 0.024 across 21 tests) both survive the correction the paper names, so lower FP engagement in children still has support. The "salience-gated" framing loses its group-difference evidence. What remains for FP–salience is the group × creativity interaction (P = 0.023), which is uncorrected and tests whether the creativity slope differs between groups, not whether adults have higher connectivity. Two other statements also rest on uncorrected results: the Discussion's DMN–memory coupling (P = 0.017, adjusted 0.062) and the Abstract's "additional effects in salience and DAN" within networks (P = 0.025 and 0.027, adjusted 0.062 each). The Abstract does not say these were corrected, but a reader is not told that they do not survive the correction applied elsewhere.

Explanations considered

Status

Suggested correction

  1. In the Results, state that after Benjamini–Hochberg correction at q = .05 only the FP–DAN between-network difference remained significant, and remove FP–salience from that sentence. Its group effect was F(1,27) = 2.434, P = 0.130 (adjusted p ≈ 0.23 over the 21 between-network tests).
  2. In the Abstract, remove FP–salience from the couplings described as greater in adults, or describe it as not significant. Revise the closing sentence so that the "salience-gated" interpretation rests only on the exploratory group × creativity interaction, and say that this interaction is uncorrected.
  3. In the Discussion, revise "reduced functional connectivity between the selected cognitive networks (FP-salience, FP-DAN, DMN-memory)" so that only FP–DAN is described as surviving correction.
  4. Report the FDR-adjusted P values for Tables 2 and 3, and state which within-network and between-network effects in the Abstract are uncorrected (within-network salience and DAN; the "broader adult-greater effects" among memory- and attention-related pairs).
  5. Minor: report FP–DAN consistently (P = 0.001 in the Results, P < 0.001 in Table 3; the F gives 0.0011), state the error degrees of freedom for 31 participants, and check the means and SDs printed for Salience–VAN, Salience–DAN and VAN–DAN, which cannot be reconciled with their F values.