Paperonium

← Back to the plain-language case

Abstract's subgroup gains in contraceptive use disagree with the paper's own Table 2

BMJ Glob Health (2026) Β· doi:10.1136/bmjgh-2024-018775 Β· PMC13250227

Summary

The abstract reports 2008–2019 gains in modern contraceptive prevalence (mCPR) for four subgroups: +12.6 and +10.0 percentage points for married women aged 15–24 and 25–49, and +19.5 and +16.9 for unmarried, sexually active women of the same ages. It states that among married women the gains "were larger in those aged 15–24 years". The paper's Table 2, the main text's only table of mCPR by age and marital status, gives +13.5 and +14.2 for the married groups and +31.5 and +21.0 for the unmarried groups. On those figures, older married women gained slightly more, the reverse of the abstract's ranking. The headline gain for all women (+15.7) and the married total both match Table 2. The paper's conclusions about drivers of the increase do not depend on these subgroup figures, but they are the only subgroup results in the abstract.

What the paper reports

All quotations are verbatim from the article as archived in PMC.

Abstract, Results:

Between 2008 and 2019, modern contraceptive prevalence among women aged 15–49 rose from 8.2% to 23.9% (+15.7 percentage points). Among married women, gains were larger in those aged 15–24 years (+12.6) than in women aged 25–49 years (+10.0). Unmarried women maintained substantially higher use, with gains of +19.5 and +16.9 points, respectively.

Table 2, "Modern contraceptive prevalence rate (mCPR, %) by age group and marital status, Sierra Leone, Demographic Health Survey (DHS) 2008–2019", excerpt (columns: population group | 2008 mCPR | N2008 | 2013 mCPR | N2013 | 2019 mCPR | N2019):

All women (15–49 years) | 8.2 | 7374 | 20.9 | 16 658 | 23.9 | 15 574
Married/in-union (15–49 years) | 6.7 | 5525 | 15.6 | 10 903 | 20.9 | 9715
Married/in-union, age 15–24 | 3.7 | 1171 | 11.8 | 2299 | 17.2 | 1842
Married/in-union, age 25–49 | 7.6 | 4353 | 16.6 | 8603 | 21.8 | 7873
Unmarried/sexually active, age 15–24† | 26.6 | 343 | 57.5 | 1472 | 58.1 | 1309
Unmarried/sexually active, age 25–49† | 21.1 | 208 | 53.3 | 586 | 42.1 | 678

Table 2 footer, excerpt:

All prevalence rates and denominators are from DHS 2008 (Table 5.4), DHS 2013 (Table 7.2) and DHS 2019 (Table 7.3), or computed as described in Methods.

Calculated values for age subgroups represent weighted averages of individual 5-year cohorts; see Methods for details.

Results, "Modern contraceptive prevalence and demand satisfied", first paragraph:

Between 2008 and 2019, Sierra Leone’s mCPR increased, from 8.2% to 23.9% among all women and from 6.7% to 20.9% among married or in-union women (DHS table 2).

Gains were observed across both married and unmarried women, with mCPR among sexually active unmarried women aged 15–24 reaching 57.5% by 2013 and remaining high in 2019 (58.1%).

Table 2 presents mCPR by marital status and age, with subgroup N calculated from original DHS reports or as weighted averages of DHS age and marital groups.

Methods, "Trend analysis":

These data sources were used to describe national and subnational trends in mCPR, with results presented as simple proportions over time.

Methods, "Decomposition analysis" (the sample of the separate decomposition model):

Analysis included women aged 15–49 who had sexual intercourse in the previous 12 months, were not pregnant or menopausal and did not self-report as infecund, regardless of parity.

The figures +12.6, +10.0, +19.5 and +16.9 do not appear as mCPR values or gains anywhere in the main text outside the abstract.

What the paper's own numbers show

Method. For each subgroup named in the abstract I subtracted the Table 2 mCPR for 2008 from the value for 2019, giving the absolute change in percentage points (pp). That is the measure the abstract uses for the all-women figure, where its "+15.7 percentage points" equals 23.9 βˆ’ 8.2. I then checked whether other readings of Table 2 could produce the abstract values: the 2008–2013 and 2013–2019 windows, relative change, rounding of each table cell (Β±0.05), and every ordered pair of cells in the table. I also checked that Table 2 is internally consistent: each 15–49 row should equal the N-weighted average of its two age rows. Finally, I compared the abstract values with the only other subgroup mCPR figures in the paper, the descriptive tables of online supplemental file 4. Every number below is printed by recompute.py.txt.

Quantity Location Reported Recomputed from the paper's own numbers
Gain, all women 15–49, 2008β†’2019 Abstract vs Table 2 row 1 +15.7 (8.2% β†’ 23.9%) 23.9 βˆ’ 8.2 = +15.7 (matches)
Gain, married 15–49, 2008β†’2019 Results text vs Table 2 6.7% β†’ 20.9% (no gain stated) 20.9 βˆ’ 6.7 = +14.2 (levels match)
Gain, married 15–24, 2008β†’2019 Abstract vs Table 2 +12.6 17.2 βˆ’ 3.7 = +13.5
Gain, married 25–49, 2008β†’2019 Abstract vs Table 2 +10.0 21.8 βˆ’ 7.6 = +14.2
Younger minus older married gain Abstract ("gains were larger in those aged 15–24 years") +2.6 pp (15–24 larger) βˆ’0.7 pp (25–49 larger)
Gain, unmarried sexually active 15–24 Abstract vs Table 2 +19.5 58.1 βˆ’ 26.6 = +31.5
Gain, unmarried sexually active 25–49 Abstract vs Table 2 +16.9 42.1 βˆ’ 21.1 = +21.0
Range of each gain if every cell is rounded to Β±0.05 Table 2 β€” married 13.4–13.6 and 14.1–14.3; unmarried 31.4–31.6 and 20.9–21.1
Married gains, other windows (15–24; 25–49) Table 2 β€” 2008β†’2013: +8.1, +9.0; 2013β†’2019: +5.4, +5.2
Relative change 2008β†’2019, married (15–24; 25–49) Table 2 β€” +364.9%, +186.8%
N-weighted average of age rows, married, 2008/2013/2019 Table 2 internal check 6.7 / 15.6 / 20.9 6.8 / 15.6 / 20.9 (table self-consistent; all-women and unmarried rows also agree within 0.1)
Gain, decomposition sample, partnered 15–24; 25–49 Supplemental file 4, descriptive table 2 5.7 β†’ 28.5; 9.5 β†’ 30 +22.8; +20.5
Gain, decomposition sample, all women 15–49 Supplemental file 4, descriptive table 1 11.7 β†’ 36 +24.3

Table 2 is internally coherent: each 15–49 row equals, within 0.1 pp, the N-weighted average of its 15–24 and 25–49 rows, and the Ns add up within one woman. The abstract's all-women gain is read off this table exactly. The four subgroup gains in the next two sentences of the abstract are not. Rounding moves each table gain by at most 0.1 pp, so it cannot account for differences of 0.9, 4.2, 12.0 and 4.1 pp. Searching all ordered pairs of Table 2 cells turns up only scattered coincidences that mix unrelated rows, years or populations. For example, 10.0 equals the married 25–49 value in 2019 minus the married 15–24 value in 2013. No pair at all gives 19.5.

Figure

The abstract's four subgroup gains, set beside the gains computed from Table 2, with the married-women ranking reversed

Figure 1. Left panel: the four subgroup gains in mCPR, 2008β†’2019, and the ranking statement as printed in the abstract (orange). Right panel: the same quantities computed from the 2008 and 2019 cells of Table 2 (blue). The dashed connectors give the size of each discrepancy in percentage points. The double-headed connector marks the married-women comparison: the abstract has the 15–24 group gaining more, Table 2 the 25–49 group (+14.2 vs +13.5). The line under the panels shows the one gain in the same abstract passage that does match Table 2, for all women aged 15–49.

Dot plot of each 2008–2019 gain: abstract value, Table 2 value, and the supplementary decomposition-sample value

Figure 2. The 2008β†’2019 gain in mCPR, in percentage points, for each group named in the abstract. Open orange circles are the abstract values. Filled blue circles are recomputed from Table 2. Open grey diamonds are the gains in the decomposition sample of online supplemental file 4 (sexually active, not pregnant, not menopausal and fecund women; no unmarried-only group is reported there). The axis starts at zero. For all women aged 15–49, the abstract and Table 2 values coincide at 15.7 (the blue dot is drawn inside the orange ring). For every subgroup, the abstract value matches neither Table 2 nor the supplement.

Why it matters

Explanations considered

Status

Suggested correction

If Table 2 is correct, the abstract's Results sentences

Among married women, gains were larger in those aged 15–24 years (+12.6) than in women aged 25–49 years (+10.0). Unmarried women maintained substantially higher use, with gains of +19.5 and +16.9 points, respectively.

could read

Among married women, gains were similar in those aged 15–24 years (+13.5) and 25–49 years (+14.2), although prevalence among the younger group rose more in relative terms (from 3.7% to 17.2%). Unmarried, sexually active women maintained substantially higher use, with gains of +31.5 and +21.0 points, respectively.

If the abstract values were instead drawn from a different source or sample, the authors could name that source in the abstract and explain why its subgroup gains differ from Table 2. Either way, the abstract's comparison of married age groups should be stated so that it agrees with the reported data.