Paperonium

← Back to the plain-language case

Abstract swaps the insured and uninsured labels on the key outpatient odds ratios

PLoS Med (2026) · doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1005087 · PMC13160435

Summary

For people with physical-psychological-cognitive multimorbidity, the Abstract reports an outpatient odds ratio of 6.22 (95% CI 5.33 to 7.25) among insured individuals and 3.40 (3.03 to 3.82) among uninsured individuals. The Results report the same two estimates and intervals with the groups reversed: 6.22 without insurance and 3.40 with insurance. Fig 5's source data (S1 Data) and the interaction model in S1 Appendix agree with the Results. The Abstract's labels also contradict the Abstract's own preceding sentence, which says the association was "attenuated" among the insured. As printed, the only number the Abstract gives for the insurance analysis points the opposite way from the paper's finding: the association with outpatient use looks 0.55 times as strong among the uninsured, when the Results give 1.83 times as strong.

What the paper reports

Abstract, Methods and findings:

Among individuals with health insurance coverage, the association between multimorbidity and outpatient care utilisation was generally attenuated. This was especially evident for those with physical-psychological-cognitive multimorbidity: insured individuals had an OR of 6.22 (95% CI [5.33, 7.25]; p < 0.001), compared with 3.40 (95% CI [3.03, 3.82]; p < 0.001) among uninsured individuals.

Results, subsection "The role of health insurance", first paragraph:

Specifically, among individuals with health insurance coverage, the association between multimorbidity and outpatient care use was generally weaker. This was particularly evident for those with physical-psychological-cognitive multimorbidity (without insurance: OR 6.22, 95% CI [5.33, 7.25]; p < 0.001; with insurance: OR 3.40, 95% CI [3.03, 3.82]; p < 0.001), physical-psychological multimorbidity (without insurance: OR 8.32, 95% CI [7.76, 8.93]; p < 0.001; with insurance: OR 3.01, 95% CI [2.76, 3.29]; p < 0.001), and single physical conditions (without insurance: OR 5.67, 95% CI [5.39, 5.97]; p < 0.001; with insurance: OR 3.53, 95% CI [3.23, 3.85]; p < 0.001).

Discussion, fifth paragraph:

In this study, the association between multimorbidity and healthcare use was less pronounced among insured individuals than among those without coverage, especially regarding outpatient services.

Author summary:

Health insurance appeared to buffer the association between multimorbidity and healthcare utilisation.

Methods, "Health insurance":

we treated health insurance at the individual level as a binary variable (covered versus not covered), encompassing public, private, or any other form of coverage.

What the paper's own numbers show

Method. I compared the Abstract's estimates with those in the Results sentence, checked each OR against its own confidence interval (the geometric midpoint of a symmetric log-scale interval should equal the point estimate), and compared both with the unrounded source data for Fig 5 in S1 Data (sheet "Figure_5"). To express the direction of the insurance difference as a single number, I computed the ratio OR(uninsured) / OR(insured) for each multimorbidity pattern. A value above 1 means the association is weaker among the insured. Its 95% CI uses the standard errors implied by the printed intervals, treating the two strata as independent; they are disjoint groups of participants, so this is a reasonable approximation. Every number below is printed by recompute.py.txt.

Quantity Location Reported Recomputed from the paper's numbers
OR, outpatient, phy-psy-cog, insured Abstract 6.22 [5.33, 7.25] 3.40 [3.03, 3.82] per Results and S1 Data (3.4033)
OR, outpatient, phy-psy-cog, uninsured Abstract 3.40 [3.03, 3.82] 6.22 [5.33, 7.25] per Results and S1 Data (6.2227)
OR, outpatient, phy-psy-cog, without / with insurance Results, "The role of health insurance" 6.22 [5.33, 7.25] / 3.40 [3.03, 3.82] geometric CI midpoints 6.22 / 3.40 (internally consistent)
Abstract vs Results estimates Abstract; Results same two estimates and CIs identical to two decimals, with the group labels exchanged
S1 Data, outpatient, no / yes insurance S1 Data, sheet Figure_5 phy-psy-cog 6.2227 / 3.4033; phy-psy 8.3225 / 3.0145; single physical 5.6723 / 3.5259 round to the Results values 6.22 / 3.40, 8.32 / 3.01, 5.67 / 3.53
OR(uninsured) / OR(insured), phy-psy-cog derived from Results "generally weaker" among insured 1.83 [1.51, 2.22], z = 6.1
Same ratio, using the Abstract's labels derived from Abstract "generally attenuated" among insured 0.55 [0.45, 0.66]: stronger among insured, contradicting the Abstract's own sentence
OR(uninsured) / OR(insured), phy-psy derived from Results 8.32 vs 3.01 2.76 [2.47, 3.09] (same direction as the Results)
OR(uninsured) / OR(insured), single physical derived from Results 5.67 vs 3.53 1.61 [1.45, 1.78] (same direction as the Results)
Multimorbidity × insurance interaction, phy-psy-cog, outpatient S1 Appendix, Table N OR 0.66, p < 0.001 below 1, so weaker among the insured (agrees with the Results); stratified ratio insured / uninsured = 3.4033 / 6.2227 = 0.547

A minor side note that is not part of the finding: the S1 Data bounds for the uninsured phy-psy-cog estimate, 5.3362 and 7.2565, round to [5.34, 7.26]. The paper prints [5.33, 7.25] in both the Abstract and the Results, which looks like truncation rather than rounding. This does not affect any conclusion.

Figure

Abstract and Results give the same two outpatient odds ratios with the insured and uninsured labels exchanged

Figure 1. The two passages that report the insurance-stratified outpatient odds ratios for physical-psychological-cognitive multimorbidity, reduced to their key words and numbers as printed. Left (orange border): the Abstract, which says the association was "attenuated" among the insured and then gives the insured group the larger OR (6.22) and the uninsured group the smaller one (3.40). Right (blue border): the Results subsection "The role of health insurance", which gives the same estimates and CIs to two decimals with the groups the other way round: 6.22 without insurance and 3.40 with insurance. The connectors join identical estimates. Only the Results assignment fits the attenuation sentence that both passages contain, and it is the one that matches Fig 5's source data (S1 Data), the interaction model (S1 Appendix Table N) and the Discussion.

Ratio of odds ratios, uninsured over insured, for three multimorbidity patterns, with the Abstract's labelling shown separately

Figure 2. Ratio of the outpatient odds ratio among the uninsured to that among the insured, on a log scale. The thin vertical line at 1 marks no difference by insurance status; values to the right mean the association is weaker among the insured. Blue circles are recomputed from the ORs and CIs in the Results for the three patterns the paper reports. All three lie to the right of 1 (1.83, 2.76 and 1.61). The orange diamond takes the Abstract's labels at face value for physical-psychological-cognitive multimorbidity and gives 0.55 [0.45, 0.66], the mirror image of the blue estimate for the same pattern. The Abstract's labelling is the only one of the four that would mean a stronger association among the insured. Intervals assume independent strata.

Why it matters

The Abstract contains a single numerical result for the insurance analysis, and the Abstract's conclusion rests on it: "Our study highlights the potential role of health insurance in reducing socioeconomic disparities in healthcare utilisation associated with multimorbidity". As printed, those numbers say that the association between the most complex multimorbidity pattern and outpatient use was stronger, by a factor of about 1.8, among people with insurance. That is the opposite of the buffering finding the paper reports. Readers who see only the Abstract, along with indexing services, evidence summaries and systematic reviews that extract numbers from abstracts, would record the effect in the wrong direction, or would see a sentence that contradicts its own numbers and be unable to tell from the Abstract which one is right.

The paper's main conclusion is not affected. The Results, the Fig 5 source data, the interaction model in S1 Appendix, the Discussion and the Author summary all use the correct labels, and the two other patterns reported in the Results (physical-psychological, single physical) show the same direction. The error is in labelling, not in the analysis. The title, Table 1 and the Conclusions do not repeat the swapped numbers.

Explanations considered

Status

Suggested correction

In the Abstract (Methods and findings), exchange the group labels so that the sentence agrees with the Results, Fig 5 and S1 Data:

This was especially evident for those with physical-psychological-cognitive multimorbidity: uninsured individuals had an OR of 6.22 (95% CI [5.33, 7.25]; p < 0.001), compared with 3.40 (95% CI [3.03, 3.82]; p < 0.001) among insured individuals.

Optionally, the authors could also check the printed bounds of the uninsured CI (S1 Data gives 5.3362 and 7.2565, which round to 5.34 and 7.26).