Paperonium

โ† Back to the plain-language case

Abstract reports low-birth-weight estimates, including a nominally significant ASD effect, as preterm-birth results

Lancet Reg Health Eur (2025) ยท doi:10.1016/j.lanepe.2025.101247 ยท PMC11910110

Summary

The abstract's Findings say that, compared with term birth, preterm birth was associated with higher ASD symptoms, 3ยท23 (95% CI 0ยท37, 6ยท08) percentiles, and give preterm effects of 4ยท15 for ADHD symptoms and โˆ’5ยท44 for non-verbal IQ. All three values, estimates and both CI limits, are the cells of the birth weight <2500 g row of Table 4, not the gestational age <37 wk row. Table 4's preterm row gives ASD 0ยท60 (โˆ’2ยท60, 3ยท79), which is null (p โ‰ˆ 0ยท71 recomputed from the CI), ADHD 2ยท51 and non-verbal IQ โˆ’3ยท41; the Results and Discussion agree with the table and state explicitly that preterm birth was not associated with ASD symptoms. A reader of the abstract alone would therefore take away a pretermโ€“ASD association that the paper's own analysis did not find, and preterm effects on ADHD and IQ about 1ยท6 times larger than estimated.

What the paper reports

Abstract, Findings (second sentence):

As compared to term birth, preterm birth was associated with higher internalizing problems (difference 3ยท43 (95% CI: 2ยท52, 4ยท33)) and externalizing problems (difference 2ยท31 (95% CI: 1ยท16, 3ยท46)), ADHD symptoms (difference 4ยท15 (95% CI: 3ยท15, 5ยท16)), ASD symptoms (difference 3ยท23 (95% CI: 0ยท37, 6ยท08)), and lower non-verbal IQ (difference -5ยท44 (95% CI: -7ยท44, -3ยท44)).

Results, "Birth outcomes, emotional, behavior and cognitive outcomes", paragraph 2:

As compared to children born term, those born preterm had increased scores for ADHD symptoms in childhood (2ยท51 percentiles (95% CI: 1ยท61, 3ยท40)) and early adolescence (2ยท33 percentiles (95% CI: 1ยท16, 3ยท50)).

Not preterm birth, but low birth weight was associated with ASD symptoms (3ยท23 percentiles (95% CI: 0ยท37, 6ยท08)).

Preterm birth and low birth weight were also associated with a -3ยท41 percentiles (95% CI: -5ยท46, -1ยท36) and -5ยท44 percentiles (95% CI: -7ยท44, -3ยท44) lower Non-verbal IQ in childhood respectively.

Discussion, paragraph 4:

The lack of association for preterm birth might also be explained by lower numbers since ASD was only available in two cohorts, that have both a rather healthy population, without extremely premature children.

Table 4 (confounder model; childhood ADHD, ASD and non-verbal IQ columns), as printed:

<37 | 2ยท51 (1ยท61, 3ยท40)โˆ—โˆ—n = 4522 | โ€ฆ | 0ยท60 (-2ยท60, 3ยท79)n = 279 | -3ยท41 (-5ยท46, -1ยท36)โˆ—โˆ—n = 780

<2500 | 4ยท15 (3ยท15, 5ยท16)โˆ—โˆ—n = 3531 | โ€ฆ | 3ยท23 (0ยท37, 6ยท08)โˆ—N = 353 | -5ยท44 (-7ยท44, -3ยท44)โˆ—โˆ—N = 821

Table 4 footer: "โˆ—p value < 0ยท05, โˆ—โˆ—p value < 0ยท01". Methods, Statistical analysis:

To correct for multiple testing, we used the Bonferroni correction method taking account for five outcomes and specified multiple-test corrected p-values as <0ยท01.

What the paper's own numbers show

Method. Each number in the abstract's "preterm birth" sentence was matched, estimate and both CI limits, against every relevant cell of Tables 3 and 4 (confounder model). For each cell a standard error was recovered from the printed 95% CI as SE = (upper โˆ’ lower)/3ยท92 and a two-sided Wald p-value computed. The basic-model (Table S5) and complete-case (Table S9) results in the paper's Appendix A were checked the same way, to rule out that the abstract quotes a different model or analysis set. All arithmetic is in recompute.py.txt.

Quantity Location Reported Recomputed / located
ASD symptoms, "preterm birth" Abstract, Findings 3ยท23 (0ยท37, 6ยท08) Identical to Table 4 <2500 g ASD cell (N = 353); not in the <37 wk row
ASD symptoms, preterm <37 wk Table 4 0ยท60 (โˆ’2ยท60, 3ยท79), n = 279, no asterisk SE 1ยท630, z 0ยท37, p = 0ยท71; CI includes 0
ASD symptoms, birth weight <2500 g Table 4; Results 3ยท23 (0ยท37, 6ยท08)โˆ— SE 1ยท457, z 2ยท22, p = 0ยท027 (matches โˆ—; does not meet the paper's Bonferroni p < 0ยท01)
ADHD symptoms (childhood), "preterm birth" Abstract, Findings 4ยท15 (3ยท15, 5ยท16) Identical to Table 4 <2500 g cell; preterm cell is 2ยท51 (1ยท61, 3ยท40), p < 0ยท001; abstract/preterm ratio 1ยท65
Non-verbal IQ, "preterm birth" Abstract, Findings โˆ’5ยท44 (โˆ’7ยท44, โˆ’3ยท44) Identical to Table 4 <2500 g cell; preterm cell is โˆ’3ยท41 (โˆ’5ยท46, โˆ’1ยท36), p = 0ยท001; ratio 1ยท60
Internalizing (childhood), "preterm birth" Abstract, Findings 3ยท43 (2ยท52, 4ยท33) Identical to Table 3 <37 wk childhood cell (correct)
Externalizing, "preterm birth" Abstract, Findings 2ยท31 (1ยท16, 3ยท46) Table 3 <37 wk early-adolescence cell; the childhood cell is 2ยท28 (1ยท43, 3ยท13). Correct exposure, different age window from the other four numbers (minor)
ASD, preterm, basic model Appendix A, Table S5 1ยท35 (โˆ’1ยท89, 4ยท60) z 0ยท82, p = 0ยท41; not the abstract value
ASD, <2500 g, basic model Appendix A, Table S5 3ยท71 (0ยท82, 6ยท60)โˆ— not the abstract value; no basic-model cell equals any abstract value
ASD, preterm, complete-case Appendix A, Table S9 โˆ’0ยท50 (โˆ’4ยท41, 3ยท41) z โˆ’0ยท25, p = 0ยท80; no complete-case cell equals any abstract value
LGA vs AGA, ADHD (side finding) Abstract vs Table 5 Abstract โˆ’1ยท09 (โˆ’1ยท73, 0ยท45); Table 5 โˆ’1ยท09 (โˆ’1ยท73, โˆ’0ยท45)โˆ— With +0ยท45 the CI midpoint is โˆ’0ยท64, not โˆ’1ยท09, and the interval would include 0; Table 5's interval is symmetric about โˆ’1ยท09 (p = 0ยท0008). The abstract upper limit has lost its minus sign

Three of the five numbers in the "preterm birth" sentence (ADHD, ASD, non-verbal IQ) reproduce the confounder-model <2500 g row of Table 4 exactly, to two decimals in all three positions; none of them matches any preterm cell in the main, basic-model or complete-case tables, in any age window. In every one of these analyses the preterm ASD estimate is null. The first two numbers (internalizing, externalizing) do come from the preterm row of Table 3.

Figure

Diagram: the abstract's ASD estimate attributed to preterm birth is the Table 4 low-birth-weight cell; the Table 4 preterm cell is null

Figure 1. The abstract's ASD value (orange, as reported) is identical in estimate and both CI limits to the Table 4 row for birth weight <2500 g, not the row for gestational age <37 wk. The preterm row, 0ยท60 (โˆ’2ยท60, 3ยท79) with n = 279, has a recomputed p of 0ยท71; the low-birth-weight row has p = 0ยท027 (blue, recomputed from the printed 95% CIs). The Results and Discussion text (right) attribute the association to low birth weight and describe a lack of association for preterm birth.

Dot-and-interval plot of the five abstract "preterm birth" values next to the paper's preterm estimates

Figure 2. For each outcome in the abstract's "preterm birth" sentence, the value stated in the abstract (orange circles) is plotted against the preterm (<37 wk vs 37โ€“42 wk) childhood estimate from Tables 3 and 4 (blue squares), with 95% CIs on one axis of outcome-percentile differences and a reference line at no difference. The right-hand column names the table cell each abstract value reproduces and the recomputed p-value of the preterm cell. Internalizing and externalizing agree; ADHD and non-verbal IQ are overstated by about 60%; for ASD the abstract's interval excludes 0 while the paper's preterm interval is centred near 0.

Why it matters

Explanations considered

Status

As of 2026-10-23:

Suggested correction

In the Abstract, Findings, replace the second sentence so that each estimate is attributed to its own exposure and age window, for example:

As compared to term birth, preterm birth was associated with higher internalizing problems (difference 3ยท43 (95% CI: 2ยท52, 4ยท33)), externalizing problems (difference 2ยท28 (95% CI: 1ยท43, 3ยท13)) and ADHD symptoms (difference 2ยท51 (95% CI: 1ยท61, 3ยท40)) in childhood, and with lower non-verbal IQ (difference โˆ’3ยท41 (95% CI: โˆ’5ยท46, โˆ’1ยท36)), but not with ASD symptoms (difference 0ยท60 (95% CI: โˆ’2ยท60, 3ยท79)). Low birth weight (<2500 g) was associated with higher ADHD symptoms (difference 4ยท15 (95% CI: 3ยท15, 5ยท16)) and ASD symptoms (difference 3ยท23 (95% CI: 0ยท37, 6ยท08)) and lower non-verbal IQ (difference โˆ’5ยท44 (95% CI: โˆ’7ยท44, โˆ’3ยท44)).

If the early-adolescence externalizing value (2ยท31 (1ยท16, 3ยท46)) is preferred, label it as early adolescence. Consider noting that the low-birth-weight ASD association (p โ‰ˆ 0ยท03) does not meet the paper's Bonferroni threshold of p < 0ยท01. In the next sentence on large size for gestational age, correct the ADHD interval to (95% CI: โˆ’1ยท73, โˆ’0ยท45), as in Table 5. The same corrections apply to the abstract text repeated in the STROBE checklist (Appendix A, item 1(b)).