Paperonium

← Back to the plain-language case

Rapa Nui population estimates in Table 3 use 760 ha, but 0.76 km² is 76 ha

Sci Adv (2024) ¡ doi:10.1126/sciadv.ado1459 ¡ PMC11192071

Summary

The paper maps 0.76 km² of rock gardens on Rapa Nui and uses this area in Table 3 to estimate how many people sweet potatoes grown in the gardens could have fed. Since 1 km² = 100 ha, 0.76 km² is 76 ha, but Table 3 enters 760 ha (380 ha and 126.67 ha for the two shifting-cultivation scenarios). The table's own arithmetic reproduces every printed population from these hectare figures, so all six "this study" estimates are ten times what the paper's stated area implies. With 76 ha, the maximum falls from 3,901 to about 390 people, and the "~3000" that the paper says "matches historical accounts" becomes about 300. The abstract's conclusion, that gardening could not support the large populations assumed before, is unaffected and, if anything, stronger.

What the paper reports

Results, after the model output was cleaned by hand:

The resulting dataset contains a total of 0.76 km2 of rock gardens across Rapa Nui (Fig. 1).

Discussion, first paragraph:

Ladefoged et al.’s (26) mulching estimates ranged from 4.3 to 21.1 km2. Our study estimates indicate that the total area of rock gardening is 0.76 km2, approximately one-fifth of the most conservative previous estimates, including many misclassified colluvium areas, lava flows, and roadways.

Discussion, "Reevaluating population estimates", first paragraph, giving the conversion factors:

Puleston et al. (6) rely on estimates of sweet potato yields to approximate the pre-European contact population size of Rapa Nui and report that 1 ton/year of sweet potato produces a yield of 2809 kcal/day.

(maximum of 2785 kcal per day per person)

Table 3 (column header, then the six "This study" rows):

Cultivation frequency | N availability | Sweet potato yield (tons/ha/year) | Rock garden area estimate | Land available for rock gardening (ha) | Sweet potato yield (kcal/day) | Number of individuals supported

Continuous | Low | 1.46 | This study | 760 | 3,116,886.4 | 1,119 Continuous | High | 5.09 | This study | 760 | 10,866,335.6 | 3,901 Shifting (5/5) | Low | 2.38 | This study | 380 | 2,540,459.6 | 912 Shifting (5/5) | High | 8.00 | This study | 380 | 8,539,360.0 | 3,066 Shifting (15/3) | Low | 5.61 | This study | 126.67 | 1,996,075.4 | 716 Shifting (15/3) | High | 17.60 | This study | 126.67 | 6,262,384.6 | 2,248

Table 3 caption:

We use the same ratios as Puleston et al. (6) (100% for continuous, 50% for shifting 5 years off 5 years on, and 25% for shifting 15 years off 3 years on).

Discussion, conclusions drawn from Table 3:

In contrast, baseline estimates of the population size using our new rock gardening data suggest that population sizes could not have exceeded 4000 (Table 3).

The average carrying capacity of rock gardening calculated in this study is ~2000. If we add 50% to this estimate to account for marine and additional terrestrial foods from nonmulched areas, we arrive at an estimated carrying capacity of ~3000 people. This value matches historical accounts of population size at the time of European arrival in the 18th century (44, 45).

Our estimates suggest that the maximum population supported by rock gardening is not ~17,000 as claimed through Ladefoged et al.’s (26) rock gardening calculations but just 3901 using our measurements.

Introduction, paragraph setting out the study's aims:

We demonstrate that the extent of rock gardening cultivation found in the occupied coastal areas comports with estimates of the population from observations made by early European visitors to the island in the 18th century, which is about 3000 (36).

Abstract, final sentence:

We show that the extent of this agricultural infrastructure is substantially less than previously claimed and likely could not have supported the large population sizes that have been assumed.

What the paper's own numbers show

Method. Table 3 follows the model the Discussion describes: daily kcal = yield (tons/ha/year) × area (ha) × 2809, and people supported = kcal ÷ 2785. I first applied this to all twelve printed rows, using the printed hectares, to establish which area each row actually used. I then recomputed the six "this study" rows with the paper's stated 0.76 km² = 76 ha, keeping the yields and the area fractions the table applies (1, 1/2 and 1/6 for continuous, 5/5 and 15/3 cultivation). Finally I checked which of the two areas fits the paper's own verbal comparisons with earlier estimates. Every number below is printed by recompute.py.txt.

Quantity Location Reported Recomputed from the paper's own numbers
Mapped rock-garden area Results; Discussion 0.76 km² = 76 ha (1 km² = 100 ha)
Land available, continuous Table 3 760 ha 76 ha; 760 ha would be 7.6 km²
Land available, shifting 5/5 and 15/3 Table 3 380 ha; 126.67 ha 38 ha; 12.67 ha (380/760 = 1/2; 126.67/760 = 1/6)
Printed populations reproduced from printed hectares Table 3, all 12 rows e.g. 1,119; 3,901; 16,089 1,119.2; 3,901.7; 16,089.0 (every row agrees to rounding)
People supported, continuous, low N / high N Table 3 1,119 / 3,901 111.9 / 390.2
People supported, shifting 5/5, low N / high N Table 3 912 / 3,066 91.2 / 306.6
People supported, shifting 15/3, low N / high N Table 3 716 / 2,248 71.7 / 224.9
Ratio printed / recomputed, each row Table 3 — 10.00 (9.99 for one row)
Upper bound Discussion "could not have exceeded 4000" about 390
Maximum Discussion "just 3901" 390.2
Average of the six rows Discussion "~2000" 1,993.7 as printed; 199.4 with 76 ha
Average + 50% for other foods Discussion "~3000", "matches historical accounts" 2,990.5 as printed; 299.1 with 76 ha (10% of ~3000)
Previous minimum / this study Discussion: "approximately one-fifth" ~1/5 4.3/0.76 = 5.7 (fits 0.76 km²); 4.3/7.6 = 0.57 (7.6 km² would exceed the previous minimum)
Previous range / this study Discussion, last section: "between 5 and 20 times too high" 5 to 20 5.7 to 27.8 with 0.76 km²; 0.57 to 2.8 with 7.6 km²

Three smaller points, none of which affects the factor of ten:

Figure

The paper's 0.76 km² becomes 760 ha in Table 3 instead of 76 ha, and the tenfold difference carries through to the maximum, the average and the 50%-adjusted carrying capacity

Figure 1. The calculation chain from the mapped area to the carrying capacity the paper compares with historical accounts. The left column (orange outline) gives the values printed in Table 3 and the Discussion; the right column (blue outline) gives the values recompute.py.txt obtains from the same formula and the paper's stated 0.76 km². The two columns diverge at one step only, the conversion of km² to hectares (shaded): 0.76 km² is 76 ha, and Table 3 uses 760 ha. Every later value differs by the same factor of ten. Maximum: continuous cultivation, high soil nitrogen (5.09 t/ha/yr × ha × 2809 ÷ 2785). Average: mean of the six "This study" rows of Table 3.

All six Table 3 scenarios and their averages, as printed and as recomputed with 76 ha

Figure 2. People supported in each of the six "This study" scenarios of Table 3 (cultivation frequency × soil nitrogen), and the average of the six with and without the paper's 50% addition for marine and other foods. Orange: the table's printed values, computed from 760, 380 and 126.67 ha (for the two summary rows, the mean of the printed values, which the text rounds to ~2000 and ~3000). Blue: the same formula with 76, 38 and 12.67 ha. The vertical line marks the ~3000 of historical accounts that the paper says its adjusted estimate matches. The horizontal axis is logarithmic, so the constant factor of ten appears as equal-length connectors; all values are drawn from recompute.py.txt.

Why it matters

Explanations considered

Status

Suggested correction

If the mapped area is 0.76 km², Table 3's "This study" rows should read 76, 38 and 12.67 ha, with kcal/day and people supported of about 311,687 and 112 (continuous, low N), 1,086,634 and 390 (continuous, high N), 254,046 and 91 (5/5, low N), 853,936 and 307 (5/5, high N), 199,608 and 72 (15/3, low N), and 626,220 and 225 (15/3, high N). The Discussion would then read "could not have exceeded ~400" instead of 4000, an average of ~200 instead of ~2000, ~300 instead of ~3000 after the 50% addition, and a maximum of 390 instead of 3901. The sentences on agreement with the ~3000 of historical accounts, in the Introduction and the Discussion, would need to be revised accordingly.

Because the deposited raster sums to a third value (10.28 km² at its native cell size), the authors may wish to state how the 0.76 km² total was computed and confirm it before revising Table 3. Whatever the confirmed area, the text and Table 3 should use the same figure. The caption's "25%" for 15/3 shifting cultivation should be changed to the 1/6 the table applies (or the table recomputed with 25%), and the minimum of the earlier estimate should be given consistently as 4.3 or 4.9 km².