Protein evolution · eLife · 2024
“Higher than random chance”: 12 of 17. Chance does that 1 time in 14, too often.
How often chance alone gives a result this strong if touching does nothing
The paper says
Do touching parts of a protein machine evolve in step (speeding up and slowing down together) more than other parts? In 12 of 17 machines they did. The paper’s test says chance alone would give that only 1 time in 41 (p = 0.0245).
Its own data show
By the paper’s own setup, if touching does nothing each machine is a coin flip: 12 of 17 is like 12 heads in 17 tosses. Chance alone gives 12 or more heads 1 time in 14 (p = 0.072), missing the usual 1-in-20 bar. The paper’s 1 in 41 counts only 13 or more.
This test asks how often chance alone gives a result at least as strong as the one seen, so 12 itself counts. Leaving out exactly 12 heads (1 time in 21) turns 1 in 14 into 1 in 41. Corrected, only one of the paper’s three checks that touching matters passes. Its main finding, no general link, stands.