Marine biology · Sci Adv · 2020
Plankton paper: chance alone gives its light/dark shell gap under 1 in 10,000. Its own counts: 1 in 12.
How often chance alone would produce this gap if light made no difference
The paper says
A single plankton made copies of itself, whose shells spiral left or right. Of those lit 12 hours a day, 87.5% spiraled left; of those kept always dark, 50%. The paper says chance alone would give a gap this big under 1 time in 10,000.
Its own data show
Its percentages and the 20 shells it checked fit only 7 of 8 in light and 6 of 12 in dark. The test the paper names gives 1 in 12; other common tests, 1 in 5 to 1 in 23. Its printed 9 for light can’t give 87.5%; 8 of 9 gives 1 in 16.
“1 in N” is how often chance alone would produce a gap this big if light made no difference. 1 in 12, like guessing a stranger’s birth month, misses the usual bar of 1 in 20. The paper uses the gap to suggest light may affect spiral direction, the usual way to tell this plankton from a close relative.