Paperonium

← Back to the plain-language case

Abstract reverses the direction of both age effects on cortical thickness reported in Table 3

Brain (2023) Β· doi:10.1093/brain/awad100 Β· PMC10473572

Summary

In its brain-resilience results, the abstract says that "older age was associated with higher baseline cortical thickness and slower rate of cortical thinning independent of tau". The paper's own Table 3 reports a negative age coefficient on AD-signature cortical thickness (standardized Ξ² = βˆ’0.49, 95% CI βˆ’0.613 to βˆ’0.366, P < 0.001) and a negative Time Γ— Age coefficient (standardized Ξ² = βˆ’0.051, 95% CI βˆ’0.083 to βˆ’0.020, P = 0.002). Both mean that older age goes with thinner cortex and faster thinning. The Results, both relevant Discussion passages and Supplementary Table 5 all give that direction, and the printed intervals reproduce the printed t values, so the signs in the table are not typesetting slips. Only the abstract sentence states the reverse. Because the abstract is the part most often read and indexed, readers who rely on it get the direction of a secondary finding backwards; the estimates themselves and the paper's main conclusions are unaffected.

What the paper reports

Abstract, results paragraph:

Higher education also modified the negative impact of tau-PET on cortical thinning, while older age was associated with higher baseline cortical thickness and slower rate of cortical thinning independent of tau.

For contrast, the same abstract paragraph gives the cognitive-resilience result with the favourable direction attached to younger age:

Younger age, higher education and greater cortical thickness were associated with better cognitive performance at baseline.

Results, "Brain resilience", first paragraph:

In models that estimated main effects (i.e. after removing the three-way interaction term), older age was related to thinner cross-sectional AD-signature cortex [stΞ² (95%CI) = -0.49 (-0.613,-0.366), P < 0.001] and to accelerated cortical thinning [stΞ² (95%CI) = -0.051 (-0.083,-0.02), P < 0.01] independent of temporal meta-ROI tau.

Results of analyses with global tau burden were consistent with these findings (Supplementary Table 5).

Table 3 ("Results of linear mixed-effect models investigating determinants of brain resilience to tau burden in the temporal meta-ROI"), Age row. Columns: Time Γ— Tau Γ— Variable Ξ² (unstandardized | standardized | t | P), Time Γ— Variable Ξ² (same four), Variable Ξ² (same four):

Agea | 0.001 (-0.001,0.002) | 0.009 (-0.021,0.038) | 0.566 | 0.572 | -0.001 (-0.002,0) | -0.051 (-0.083,-0.02) | -3.182 | 0.002 | -0.012 (-0.015,-0.009) | -0.49 (-0.613,-0.366) | -7.774 | <0.001

Table 3 footer, on coding of the outcome and predictors:

Time (years), temporal meta-ROI tau (SUVR), age at baseline (years), educational level (years of education) and ICV (dm3) were centred and used in continuous form

The β€˜Time Γ— Variable β’ and β€˜Variable β’ coefficients are main effects from models where the non-significant interaction term was removed.

Methods, "Determinants":

For the current study, age (in years) was defined as the age at the time of the tau-PET scan

Discussion, first paragraph:

While there was no evidence for age as a moderator in brain resilience models, older age was associated with lower cortical thickness at the time of the tau-PET scan, and with faster cortical thinning over time.

Discussion, "Age and cortical thickness":

we found that younger age was associated with both higher baseline cortical thickness and slower rate of cortical thinning at similar levels of tau burden.

Conclusion:

we found that age, education, ICV and cortical thickness play a role in cognitive resilience, while age and education contribute to brain resilience.

What the paper's own numbers show

Method. The outcome of the Table 3 models is AD-signature cortical thickness in mm (a higher value is a thicker cortex), and age is continuous, centred, in years. A negative Age coefficient therefore means a thinner cortex at the tau-PET scan for older participants, and a negative Time Γ— Age coefficient means a more negative thickness slope, i.e. faster thinning, for older participants. The abstract's sentence requires both coefficients to be positive. To check that the printed signs belong to the printed statistics, I recomputed each standard error from its 95% CI (SE = (upper βˆ’ lower)/(2 Γ— 1.96)), the t value and P value that follow, and conversely the CI implied by the printed Ξ² and t. I also checked that the unstandardized and standardized rows agree, and repeated the sign check on Supplementary Table 5 (global tau, global thickness). Raw data are not available, so the models themselves cannot be refitted. Every number below is printed by recompute.py.txt.

Quantity Location Reported Recomputed from the paper's numbers
Age β†’ baseline thickness, standardized Ξ² Table 3; Results βˆ’0.49 (βˆ’0.613, βˆ’0.366), t = βˆ’7.774, P < 0.001 CI midpoint βˆ’0.4895; SE 0.0630; t βˆ’7.78; P β‰ˆ 7.5 Γ— 10⁻¹⁡; negative, CI excludes 0
Time Γ— Age β†’ rate of thinning, standardized Ξ² Table 3; Results βˆ’0.051 (βˆ’0.083, βˆ’0.02), t = βˆ’3.182, P = 0.002 (Results: P < 0.01) CI midpoint βˆ’0.0515; SE 0.0161; t βˆ’3.17; P β‰ˆ 0.0015; negative, CI excludes 0
CI rebuilt from printed Ξ² and t Table 3 as above Age βˆ’0.614 to βˆ’0.366; Time Γ— Age βˆ’0.082 to βˆ’0.020 (match the printed CIs)
Age, unstandardized (mm per year of age) Table 3 βˆ’0.012 (βˆ’0.015, βˆ’0.009) t βˆ’7.84 from the CI; negative; 10 years older β‰ˆ 0.12 mm thinner at the tau-PET scan
Time Γ— Age, unstandardized Table 3 βˆ’0.001 (βˆ’0.002, 0) negative; t from the CI is only βˆ’1.96 because the values are rounded to 3 decimals
Agreement of standardized and unstandardized rows Table 3 β€” βˆ’0.49 / βˆ’0.012 = 40.8; a printed βˆ’0.001 (βˆ’0.0015 to βˆ’0.0005) Γ— 40.8 = βˆ’0.061 to βˆ’0.020, which contains the printed βˆ’0.051
Expected thickness gap, 1 SD older vs average age, average tau Table 3 model without the three-way term β€” βˆ’0.49 SD at the tau-PET scan; βˆ’0.567 SD at the median MRI follow-up (18 months); βˆ’0.758 SD at the longest (63 months): the gap widens
Age as moderator of the tau effect (Time Γ— Tau Γ— Age) Table 3 0.009 (βˆ’0.021, 0.038), P = 0.572 t 0.60 from the CI; not significant, consistent with "independent of tau"
Age β†’ baseline thickness, global analysis Supplementary Table 5 βˆ’0.374 (βˆ’0.522 – βˆ’0.227), t = βˆ’5.001, P < 0.001 t βˆ’4.97 from the CI; negative
Time Γ— Age β†’ rate of thinning, global analysis Supplementary Table 5 βˆ’0.044 (βˆ’0.084 – βˆ’0.003), t = βˆ’2.112, P = 0.036 t βˆ’2.13 from the CI; negative
Direction stated in the abstract Abstract older β†’ higher baseline thickness, slower thinning requires Age Ξ² > 0 and Time Γ— Age Ξ² > 0; both printed coefficients are < 0

Figure

The abstract's statement of the age effects beside the Results text and Table 3 values, with t values recomputed from the printed intervals

Figure 1. The left panel holds the abstract's sentence on age and brain resilience and the direction it states. The right panel holds the Results sentence and the Table 3 Age row (standardized Ξ² with 95% CI and t), all as printed (orange). The connector marks the conflict: the two panels give opposite directions for both the baseline (cross-sectional) effect and the longitudinal (Time Γ— Age) effect. The blue lines give the t and P values recomputed from the printed confidence intervals; they match the printed t values, so the negative signs are internally consistent within the table.

Standardized age coefficients from Table 3 with 95% CIs, as printed and as rebuilt from the printed Ξ² and t, against the direction the abstract states

Figure 2. Each panel shows one Table 3 coefficient on its own symmetric axis, with zero as a thin reference line; the shaded half is the direction the abstract states (older age with thicker cortex, or with slower thinning). Orange circles and bars are the printed estimates and 95% CIs; blue squares and bars are the intervals rebuilt from the printed Ξ² and t (SE = Ξ²/t). Both intervals lie entirely on the negative side, away from the direction stated in the abstract.

Why it matters

Explanations considered

Status

As of 2026-10-23:

Suggested correction

In the abstract, change the sentence so that it states the direction reported in Table 3, the Results and the Discussion, for example:

Higher education also modified the negative impact of tau-PET on cortical thinning, while older age was associated with lower baseline cortical thickness and faster rate of cortical thinning independent of tau.

Equivalently, "younger age was associated with higher baseline cortical thickness and slower rate of cortical thinning independent of tau", which matches the wording of the Discussion. No change to the estimates, tables or conclusions appears to be needed.