Paperonium

Covid variants · PLoS Pathog · 2023

Summary: Alpha-variant Covid carried 44% less virus than the strain before. Its own table: over double.

The summary44% lessIts own table2.15× (over double)½×1×2×3×less virusmore virus
The summary44% lessIts own table2.15× (over double)½×1×2×3×less virusmore virus

How much virus Alpha infections carried, compared with the strain before

The paper says

The paper’s summary says that in unvaccinated people never known to have had Covid, infections with the Alpha variant carried 44% less virus in their test samples than infections with the strain Alpha replaced. One sentence in its results says the same.

Its own data show

Covid lab tests copy the virus’s genetic material in rounds until it is detected: more virus means fewer rounds. In the paper’s own table, after its adjustments, Alpha samples were detected 1 round sooner on average. The table converts that to 2.15 times as much virus, and its discussion section says “115% higher among Alpha.”

The paper’s rule: 3 rounds sooner means 10 times the virus, so 1 round sooner means about 2.15 times (2.15 × 2.15 × 2.15 ≈ 10). Read the other way round, the earlier strain had 54% less, not 44%. So the summary, the part most readers see, gets its first finding backwards and the wrong size.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

Viral burden is associated with age, vaccination, and viral variant in a population-representative study of SARS-CoV-2 that accounts for time-since-infection-related sampling bias · PLoS Pathog (2023) · doi:10.1371/journal.ppat.1011461